Watched this weekend and went alone. I hate going to movies like this with people because I always worry about my friends or family enjoying themselves for some odd reason lol. Going by myself I can truly focus on every second of the movie unless the environment is shytty. People getting up and down, talking, or chewing on popcorn set off a fuse in me quick lol. The crowd was okay once the movie started so I could pay attention.
First I want to say
fukk off with that you can't compare the different versions of Jokers rule. That's like people saying you can't copy someone else writing or art style and if you do you're breaking some unspoken rule. Some of the biggest artists encourage it because how are you gonna know who you are as a writer if you don't put yourself in shoes that have worked before? It's just always funny when the fans make the rules but the artists themselves most likely encourage the competition.
The "you can't do this" rule is some elite bull shyt. People can say one performance is better than the other. Stop the I have watched 1000 films per year so I make the rules as they go bull shyt. This is why we enjoy art because it's subjective and we can articulate reasons as to why one performance is better than the other. If someone makes an absolutely shytty version of the Joker we would all flat out say it sucks. But if it's someone knocking it out the park, we have to hit the "lol you fools don't even get the point..."
With that being said......
Joaquin Phoenix is the best Joker. He's literally 99.9999.9 percent of the movie. Everyone else in the film did not matter and honestly, they could have cast anyone for the other characters and it wouldn't have mattered or effected the movie in any way. Robert De Niro role could have been Plank from Ed, Edd, and Eddy and the movie would have still been fire. The quality of the film relied on Phoenix and him alone. There was no Batman to help build not only the chemistry but the movie itslef. This movie had limited violence and the theme for the movie went more towards a realistic point of view most of the other Jokers didn't have to worry about. The movie is 2 hours and 2 minutes. Phoenix is at least in 2 hours of it. If he fails the movie fails.
So much pressure, yet the film was a diamond in the dozen of shytty films we get nowadays. I hate the cliche of every film is "art". This is fukking art.