OFFICIAL Game of Holmes Season 8 Thread - A Dream of Flat Tops 4/14/19

O.Red

Veteran
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
18,078
Reputation
5,517
Daps
72,166
Reppin
NULL
Talk about moving goalposts. Y'all repeatedly try to shift focus. I've stated, repeatedly, that I have no issue with her method of execution. That's not the only time she's used it; I cited those other times and explicitly stated that no one had a problem with her burning those dudes alive.

And of course people were more upset over the Frey's killing the fukking Starks than some random no name lords. So what? That doesn't exonerate Dany. All you deranged #TargSet fools do is deflect deflect deflect!

I'll state my position one mo gain: Dany executed prisoners of war. She was wrong for that. That's the way they Tywin/Cersei Lannisters and Roose/Ramsay Boltons of the world operate. It's not how the Starks operate and I can cite several examples of this, from Robb to Ned to Jon.
Tywin didn't believe in executing POWs for what it's worth

Think back to when he arrived at Harrenhall like :beli:

 
Last edited:

gho3st

plata or plomo
Joined
Oct 27, 2012
Messages
34,758
Reputation
2,840
Daps
83,765
Reppin
2016

Oberyn's wife: This is war, fukk them kids
Yara: Take kings landing now, we have an army, a fleet and 3 dragons, city falls in a day ezpz
Olenna:"the common people loved margery, the noblemen loved her, what is left of her now? ashes" Nobody will obey you if they don't fear you.

Listen to the lannister dwarf and a dude who has to pee sitting down instead brehs :francis:

#TargSet lost :mjroast:

Yea looking back, she should have rode there and take kings landing by force :russ:
 

Stop_It_5

Veteran
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
14,723
Reputation
3,771
Daps
95,466
This is what she does. Take a L and bounce back.



Anyone that flips on the set. Has to remain off.

No disrespect but Targset isn’t the Starks our Ls are always Ws in the long run. If im wrong :mjcry:
StarkSet is so far ahead right now I'm feeling pity :wow: even I would hate to see StormBorn go out the way it's trending :huhldup: Episode 5 is yours Mhysa, do your thing and have one last moment of glory :mjgrin:
 

The Devil's Advocate

Call me Dad
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
35,890
Reputation
7,901
Daps
99,407
Reppin
Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven
I'm gonna stop you right there. No they didn't. She's invading their land. She tried to kill them!:stopitslime:

You're playing Stretch Armstrong to try to pretend that a surrendered enemy is in any way comparable to traitors who literally stabbed Jon in the heart. That's beyond retarded. You know what is comparable (tho not quite as bad) as what those traitors did to Jon? What Xaro and Doreah did to Dany in Qarth. Notice how nobody criticizes Dany for starving them to death in darkness, and they just helped some dusty nikka steal her pets. :mjlol:
No I’m playing what happened. You excusing treason and murder and acting like she should have sucked their dikks and thanked them

They know for 100% fact she is the rightful queen. They also know they are pledged to House Tyrell. They also know fighting with the Lannister’s is treason. Sams daddy says everything I just said directly to Jamie. Then goes along with it anyway

Now suddenly she was the one wrong. For coming to save her friend whose entirely family was murdered by these traitors

Then she offers freedom. No punishment. Hold all titles. Keep all land. Just say sorry and agree to what you already spoke out your own mouth. Which is I’m the queen. And when he said no. She gave the same offer to his son. Matter of fact didn’t even offer shyt. He stood up and asked to go.

So they got burned the fukk up. fukk outta here with this nonsense. That’s not a “crazy” person. Or somebody acting crazy. Or even cruel or mean. That’s not a stretch at all. Criminals get punished. fukk a slave master. fukk a traitor. She could have tortured them. 3 seconds of fire..... they was alright





But I don’t want to keep fighting over this tbh. I honestly watch the show and I’m cool with it. But when you get on the Coli, nikkas got photos, dissertations, old clips, data, info and links to every mistake that is made.

My problem is the writing doesn’t really show that Danny would say “fukk 1 million innocent people, ill burn them all”. they asked her not to kill innocent people. And she said fukk those innocent people. Women and kids.

Y’all know that’s a leap from whatever she did. You’d never hear her say fukk innocent common folk. Let alone burn them all up. It’s shyt shyt shyt writing
 
Last edited:

South Paw

Superstar
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
35,022
Reputation
1,910
Daps
40,256
Reppin
CML
StarkSet is so far ahead right now I'm feeling pity :wow: even I would hate to see StormBorn go out the way it's trending :huhldup: Episode 5 is yours Mhysa, do your thing and have one last moment of glory :mjgrin:
Last ep was a bad one for targset, both Dany and Aegon looked bad

Just a setback for a major comeback, though :blessed:
 

HarlemUSA

Lightbringer and Azor Ahai
Supporter
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
6,295
Reputation
450
Daps
11,584
StarkSet is so far ahead right now I'm feeling pity :wow: even I would hate to see StormBorn go out the way it's trending :huhldup: Episode 5 is yours Mhysa, do your thing and have one last moment of glory :mjgrin:
So far ahead.

Dany, Drogon and Greyworm got this.

We about to tie the series up next episode. Targset winning the series in 6.
 

CouldBeWorse

Superstar
Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
5,182
Reputation
2,731
Daps
42,374
Yea looking back, she should have rode there and take kings landing by force :russ:
Less innocents would have died as well. Cersei wouldn't have seen it coming and moved all the citizens into the red keep.

Basically, trusting Tyrion was the worst decision Dany ever made.

But really, making Tyrion so dumb is one of D&D biggest writing fukk ups. Season 1-4 Tyrion would have known there's was no way to convince Cersei, because he's known Cersei is a monster his whole life.

That speech in the last episode was so stupid, "You're not a monster Cersei". :hhh:.

She literally kidnapped and tortured a prostitute because she thought Tyrion liked her :gucci:

As a matter of fact, if he can look past Cersei being so evil, then Tyrion himself doesn't really give af about innocent people.
 
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
27,832
Reputation
4,742
Daps
103,731
Tywin didn't believe in executing POWs for what it's worth

Think back to when he arrived at Harrenhall like :beli:




But look how he left Harenhall for when Robb arrived...


Tywin and Roose were at logical with they’re cruelty. They’d try to get some use (be it info or work) out of you before executing you.
 
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
27,832
Reputation
4,742
Daps
103,731
No I’m playing what happened. You excusing treason and murder and acting like she should have sucked their dikks and thanked them

I’m not acting like any of that. I’ve repeatedly called them prisoners of war and compared her action to how more just folks in this world have treated POWs. And this the nonsense you type? How about you try to comprehend the argument being made before writing a wall of irrelevant text.
 

The Devil's Advocate

Call me Dad
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
35,890
Reputation
7,901
Daps
99,407
Reppin
Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven
But look how he left Harenhall for when Robb arrived...


Tywin and Roose were at logical with they’re cruelty. They’d try to get some use (be it info or work) out of you before executing you.

Dude talking silly. Tywin ordered babies murdered after the war was over. Ended TWO houses. Not just the no name lords. But the women and kids and workers and everyone involved.

But I guess that was different
 

detach

Banned
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
1,872
Reputation
6
Daps
3,680
Reppin
OHIO
Your life isn't a fictional account of a major character in an epic saga, fam. It doesn't need to, and doesn't, have a meaning.

Train someone as a multi-discipline killer for 8 seasons and there's no way they're not a candidate for the #1 killer position.

Jon was always who you were supposed to be thinking, of course he was. Just like you were supposed to be thinking Ned was going to be the hero in book one. Jon's arc has been much more about learning how to lead than how to kill. He doesn't even like killing, he just knows he's good at it. Arya loves that shyt.

For better or worse, this story's always been about the swerve. Don't get worked into a shoot.

You're using Arya chasing cats as to why she was able to become the assassin she is now. Post-trainging with them cats, she was a hostage for the next couple of seasons up until she met up with the faceless men. Her training in season 1 did absolutely nothing for her.

She was not trained for 8 seasons.

She was trained for two seasons and she was getting her ass kick for most of it. She was a failure and was kicked out.

It wasn't up until she killed Waif, that she's become the deadly assassin she is now.

Every kill was visually demostrated on camera,w completely believable and didn't insult our intelligence.

The kill on Night King was the complete opposite of that.

And I'm fine with Arya getting the kill and not Jon Snow. It's the execution that I'm not done with. Imagine the camera zooming in on Thanos and someone appearing out of thin air and killing him. Imagine the camera zooming in on Green Goblin and someone appearing out of thin air and killing him.
Imagine the camera zooming in on Apocalypse and someone appearing out of thin air and killing him. Just imagine any supervillain getting killed off in the same manner.
 
Last edited:

Chris Cool

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jun 22, 2014
Messages
31,127
Reputation
7,151
Daps
109,820
Reppin
So Cal
Stannis was in the right bruh. If Renly wasn't trying to be a celebrity and linked up with Stannis they could've snatched Joffery off that throne Asap

Who capes for Renly?:mjlol:
:russ: the audacity of Renly is what makes him great though. You gotta appreciate that shyt.

nikka literally had 0 zero claim to the throne, he knew and the people knew it. Still was like:manny: I'm claiming the throne, fukk big bro. Tried to save starkset and give ned some game, but good ol honorable ned:francis:
He raised an army and had people behind him and everything. 0 claim. The people's champ. Whole realm at war and he having jousting tournaments:wow: Serving Stannis that ether.

:childplease: no one wants you for their King.


Stannis ducked the fade and resorted to hoe tactics to get rid of him, and some nikkas in here claimed that set. :scust:

Renly would've been the goat king. Think about it.


Long live King Renly. :blessed:
 
Top