OFFICIAL Game of Holmes Season 8 Thread - A Dream of Flat Tops 4/14/19

[The Devil's Advocate]

LMAO @ the insane reaches being made to equate these scenarios to executing prisoners of wars

The Night Watch traitors were killed during a battle (amongst the other reasons that comparison is stupid).

Ollie literally stuck a knife if Jon's chest. He was found guilty for that crime and executed for that crime.

When was Robert murdering babies and kids? Tywin is blamed for murdering Rhaegar's family. Robert did send assassins after kid Viserys and baby Dany tho....cuz he's expressly described as having a CRAZED hatred for everything Targaryean! But even he on his deathbed realized and admitted he was wrong!

The house not doing fukked up shyt on the show? Starks. The house that raised Jon. The one true heir to the Iron Throne.

They tried to kill her. What the fukk? Prisoners of war? Wasn’t we walking pows with dog collars and torturing them in our recent wars?

They was actively trying to kill her 10 mins ago. They were traitors to olenna. They were traitors to the targs. They were offered not jail.... but goddamn NO SENTENCE AND FREEDOM. How many times? 3,4? Then again asked to just kneel when the son stepped up. They didn’t want to do it.

She didn’t murder prisoners of war. She gave them a choice. They chose.


Did ANY other people get a choice? Ned beheading old buddy in ep1. Did he listen? Give him a trial? Investigate the truth? Send a raven to castle black and imprison him?

No. Cut the shyt. Every character on this show done done some fukk shyt. Same starks who treated Jon and Theon like complete and utter shyt, even tho they was kids, then act shocked and surprised when Theon turns. They lucky Jon is nice cause he should have said fukk them bytches a long time ago. Sansa and her mom especially.

They ain’t no better as a house, record label or crew

 

[Birnin Zana]

yal realize dany's father was so crazy he was setting people on fire just to get an erection right?

Word, that was some next level shyt. Aerys went psycho, burning people for no damn reason. Got so crazy that even Rhaegar started plotting on the low. Dany isn’t on his level.

Also, what should Dany do if she doesn’t attack King Lansing? Laying a siege will take time and isn’t guaranteed to work. Plus Dany no longer has the advantage militarily due to her loses.

Attacking King’s Landing is what she should’ve done in the first place. Would’ve been a quick sacking of city.

Edit: Dany hasn’t even reached Joffrey’s level of madness. She did fukked up things but she has a long way to go before reaching Aerys and Joffrey.

 

[The Devil's Advocate]

You're comparing random ass nightwatch men to high born Lords.

they're already in jail. What babies and kids did Robert kill? Not to mention he admitted he was wrong ,us plus Robert was a shyt King. I don't know what you're trying to accomplish with that comparison.

3 people? So we ignoring all the bodies she piled up overseas. Just fukked up slavers bay, killed random ass Masters, guilty or not. Anybody honorable doing shyt like that? Going against the advice of her small council and shyt. Even Barristan was like you acting like your pops.

Or how about vaes dothrak? Killed the khals and shyt because fukk your law, shyt don't apply to her. She's a hypocrite.

Masters.... any nikka being called a master, deserves to die. fukk them. And their deaths lead to freeing slaves. So if someone came to America about 200 years ago and killed random “masters” would they be “mad” or doing the right damn thing?

Robert was King when Tywin did all that. Did he object? Or did he join in by also trying to kill two more targ kids? But on his death bed he said it was wrong so he’s cool? Has Danny burned any innocents? Given the order? But she mad already huh.


Khals who said they were going to imprison her for life or rape her to death? Them nikkas? The 100k soldiers had zero problems with it didn’t they?

That’s all you got in 12 years to justify a heel turn on every friend she got and the murder of 1 million completely innocent men, women and kids??


That’s a hell of a leap. I don’t know why y’all fighting so hard to protect this trash writing. She SHOULD have killed whole cities the whole time. Even Cersei had to make up lies about her to scare the people. The real story wouldn’t invoke any problems. So the writers already told on themselves right there

 

[The Devil's Advocate]

The night's watch traitors killed him

Hanging for killing someone is justice.

Terrible comparison

Didn’t they rebel and kill the Tyrell’s and attempt murder on her?

So they should have got a 3-5 year sentence and probation?

She offered the dumb motherfukkers full freedom. They turned it down. Anybody else offering murderers freedom? Y’all acting like you wrote the show. Don’t be so offended

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

They tried to kill her.

I'm gonna stop you right there. No they didn't. She's invading their land. She tried to kill them!

You're playing Stretch Armstrong to try to pretend that a surrendered enemy is in any way comparable to traitors who literally stabbed Jon in the heart. That's beyond retarded. You know what is comparable (tho not quite as bad) as what those traitors did to Jon? What Xaro and Doreah did to Dany in Qarth. Notice how nobody criticizes Dany for starving them to death in darkness, and they just helped some dusty nikka steal her pets.

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

The night's watch traitors killed him

Hanging for killing someone is justice.

Terrible comparison

Dany may not go full crazy, but #TargSet has already lost their minds.

 

[Spiritual Stratocaster]

Didn’t they rebel and kill the Tyrell’s and attempt murder on her?

So they should have got a 3-5 year sentence and probation?

She offered the dumb motherfukkers full freedom. They turned it down. Anybody else offering murderers freedom? Y’all acting like you wrote the show. Don’t be so offended

Stannis tells people to follow the Lord of Light or burn alive and you brehs on here called him a sick b*stard
@Soundbwoy
@fact

 

[42 Monks]

Stannis tells people to follow the Lord of Light or burn alive and you brehs on here called him a sick b*stard
@Soundbwoy
@fact

yeah when he set his daughter on fire for good luck right before getting his army slaughtered

 

[Spiritual Stratocaster]

yeah when he set his daughter on fire for good luck right before getting his army slaughtered

Nah this was happening before that.

So let me ask

Should stannis have sought another solution besides burning an innocent child alive?

 

[42 Monks]

Nah this was happening before that.

So let me ask

Should stannis have sought another solution besides burning an innocent child alive?

before that stannis was one of the most popular characters around the internet people didn't even trip when he burned mance's ass to golden brown crisp

yal are just as desperate to force shyt as these lazy ass writers. no one gave a shyt about him burning people. he was just unlikeable as fukk specifically in contrast to Renly.

"should he have found another solution to burning HIS DAUGHTER alive for nothing but hopes of good luck?" yes like not fukking doing it and that's when everyone in the world and outside bushed him. the fukk yal even be going on about IMMEDIATELY moved a goal post too fukk

 

[Spiritual Stratocaster]

before that stannis was one of the most popular characters around the internet people didn't even trip when he burned mance's ass to golden brown crisp

yal are just as desperate to force shyt as these lazy ass writers. no one gave a shyt about him burning people. he was just unlikeable as fukk specifically in contrast to Renly.

"should he have found another solution to burning HIS DAUGHTER alive for nothing but hopes of good luck?" yes like not fukking doing it and that's when everyone in the world and outside bushed him. the fukk yal even be going on about IMMEDIATELY moved a goal post too fukk

 

[SmokyQuartz]

When Jaime come through and stab that crazy bytch

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

before that stannis was one of the most popular characters around the internet people didn't even trip when he burned mance's ass to golden brown crisp

yal are just as desperate to force shyt as these lazy ass writers. no one gave a shyt about him burning people. he was just unlikeable as fukk specifically in contrast to Renly.

"should he have found another solution to burning HIS DAUGHTER alive for nothing but hopes of good luck?" yes like not fukking doing it and that's when everyone in the world and outside bushed him. the fukk yal even be going on about IMMEDIATELY moved a goal post too fukk

Nah, folks were shytting on #StannisSet for burning Lords alive on Dragonstone going back to season 2. Let's not rewrite history.

 

[42 Monks]

Nah, folks were shytting on #StannisSet for burning Lords alive on Dragonstone going back to season 2. Let's not rewrite history.

like it was worse than what anyone else was doing? straight up revisionist history lol. people were more upset that the frey's killed folks that were invited over for dinner

its crazy we gotta spin preferred methods of execution by house/ruler into a warcrime just to ignore the context in order to prop up some bullshyt... yal want to make fire a big deal while cersei had a fukkin zombie rape a nun to death

 

[HiiiPower]

The fact people are really expecting a bunch of extra dragons born from Drogon to join the fight in the next episode is proof that a lot of got fans are dumb, and will be mad at the show when it doesn’t happen