I think the grander the concept, the better the Titus Andronicus album. It's been proved by The Monitor being a seemingly impossible Civil War themed album that simultaneously has a linear narrative of a failed move from New Jersey to Boston and remains a punk album despite most songs being 6+ minutes & involving pianos, strings, bagpipes, etc... with multiple movements within each song and the structure within each song often entirely flipping on its head during the composition. It's amazing that, with all the risks it takes and odds stacked against the imagined concept of such an album, it still ended up being the best rock album of the decade thus far.
And while I love their first album, a drone-laden, grimy, moody, atmospheric album and their last, a stripped down straight punk album (although bookended by a manifesto & a blues anthem and centered by a sonically adventurous song delving into the lead singer's eating disorder), The Monitor remains the shiniest jewel in the discography for the risks it takes and succeeds at and the way the band is able to hit those heights and elevate to one of those higher levels to become something timeless and everlasting.
All that said, the new album hits & possibly surpasses the previous efforts with knocking a gigantic concept out the park. This time out, they're delivering a 90+ min punk rock opera about manic depression that has characters meeting their doppelgangers, traveling through time, fighting mystery beasts and falling in love. There are Pogues & Daniel Johnston covers (& the final song is a majestic Johnston tribute in spirit) that help navigate this rocky trip that Patrick Stickles invites us along in his turbulent mind and, yet again, the band is justified in the risks it takes as it splashes us in these waters we might never otherwise navigate in music. The lyrics are immaculate (and Patrick helped expand on many of them already:
http://genius.com/albums/Titus-andronicus/The-most-lamentable-tragedy ), the music is incredible and the concept is novel & engrossing. Songs like (S)he Said/(S)he said & Dimed Out & Fired Up are nothing short of amazing. As always, it remains very punk based, so it might not be everyone's speed, but it's definitely one of the best albums of the year & gives Titus 2 undeniable entries into best of the decade already.
I'm not going to link it b/c it leaked a full month+ early (officially out 7/28) and, as a touring band that just jumped to a new label (whose early press copies are probably why it's out already- wtf Merge?), they're going to to need as much support as they can get. But you internet savvy people already know how to find it without me saying so and I suggest anyone who does support by eventually copping or at least see them live and/or cop some merch b/c they're the only band currently worthy of demanding your attention. Also here:
http://www.mergerecords.com/presskits_mrg527 you can find a song by song breakdown of the concept by the band w/ the press kit pdfs.
Honestly album of the year.