Good points, though more context has to be provided:
•the fact that GDP NY is larger than both LA and Chi combined says more about Chicago than it says about LA. GDP LA is still 60% of NY's by itself, and per the latest numbers available (2018 which highlighted 2010-18), GDP LA is growing 11% faster than GDP NY in the 2010s...
I could have just left it at "bigger than LA" the point i was trying to make was that la and chi town are number 2 and 3 respectively. If within that coupling- chicago bares a burden, i would argue that's beside the point
GDP is heavily weighted on corporate base and the fact that NY is a few hundred years older is the reason that it has a higher concentration if corporate headquarters. If the nation got a reset to start from scratch today, in 2020, half the HQs would be in LA, but of course many of the old money/big money powers are damn near as old as LA itself, so it makes sense. As it is, LA still has the second highest level of corporate and media presence, that's nothing to sneeze at given all the cities it has leapfrogged in the last century that had a head start on concentrating power, wealth, and influence...
Im not sure where the location of headquarters has to do with gross domestic product. Chicago dallas and houston have more than LA but not a bigger city economy
LA is the staple of the west going into the pacific a company,however old, would and could relocate if need be im not sure age has much to do with it. Again NYC can play this game with far older cities globally. Whatever the premier city of the west coast was to be, was bound to leap frog anything in middle america. Chicago has the age, the great lakes and dominance over the midwest. LA has the other end of the country, the big state of california-to include tucked away from the clutter of the east coast, the west and the pacific.
So LA has the faster growing economy and it can't go unmentioned that in every metric across the board, LA, which was just entering the radar as a midsize city in 1900, has closed the gap between it and NY in 12 consecutive decades. Economically sure NY has a sizable lead, but its lead has shrunken vs LA every era and no other city in the entire history of the US has ever been as close to NY as LA has been the last 30-35 years, unless you want to count the 1700s when Philly and Boston were more or less equals...
As of having the faster growing economy in every metric- im not sure what source your using to project that. The global cities index doesn't portray this. For instance im not sure if LA is a bigger tech hub than nyc at this point, nor banking
•there are multiple studies that grade cities and take everything into account. LA isn't going to be ahead of NY in any but again, the fact that LA is universally recognized as the US #2 and a Top 5-10 global city in the entire planet, to me that says more about other cities and how LA has surpassed them, than it says about LA trailing NY...
I agree. I dont see LA as being number 2 to new york per se
•it's disingenuous to say NY has no competition from LA and its only competition is from overseas. It isn't true and is disproved across a variety of sectors in contemporary American life from education reputation to government pull to tourism to anything else...
Domestic for sure. NYC is not a primate city, it shares resources with multiple city's on the east coast alone. But you said it held JUST AS MUCH GRAVITAS which is false
We won't be here to see it, but it will be very interesting to see where NY and LA stand next to each other in 2120. NY has the benefit of size and age working in its favor more than anything at this point, and while I agree that NY overall is a step ahead of LA, there is no massive gap by any stretch of the imagination. Also the fact that they are on opposite coasts helps both, as LA has sway and influence over a wide geographic area and population base just like NY....
Agreed as stated above
There's no type of shopping or type of food or type of entertainment or type of outdoor activity that can be seen or done in NY, that can't be done in LA. And that's the lived experience to most people daily lives, and the fact that LA is the only city in the US and one of only a handful in the world that can say that vs NY, speaks volumes on how the two cities are closer in stature than not...