Dope explanation and hopefully people read it and stop telling us that we don't like Hit Boy because he's not a 90's era producer. We've explained this every time in detail.
I always point to these as the easiest example since they're the "same" beat:
The Easy Moe Bee version is unmastered and still sounds better because it has warmth and texture. The high hats are cutting through the mix. They stand out and give the beat its bounce. The drums have swing and are lively. My head is nodding as soon as they come in. The guitar riff at :28 is pronounced and you feel it when it hits right before Nas starts the chorus and every time they come in after. The vocal sample comes in and isn't clashing with the other sounds. Everything blends well and the beat is soulful. Again this is unmastered.
Hit Boy added more sounds but it still isn't matching the original. When the drums kick in listen to how weak the high hats sound vs the original. They're not cutting through and the beat lacks bounce. The drums are soft. Go to :28 again and listen for that guitar riff. You can barely hear it. The guitar keeps playing but he has the synth and other sounds playing on top of it so everything is competing for your ear. The sounds are getting lost.
Hit Boy on making the beat:3
He admits he couldn't get the drums to cut through and they don't in the final version.
When the verse starts in the original the synth and vocal sample are gone so it's just the main sample, bass, drums, and Nas' vocals. The guitar riff drops in every 8th bar. When the verse is over all the other sounds are reintroduced. Hit Boy's version has the sounds playing with the verse so the beat isn't as clean because he's not emphasizing certain sounds and letting your ears focus on the rapper.
This is a consistent problem with his beats.
Thanks for this post. I'm not a producer so I don't get all the technical shyt...but the example here makes me see what people are saying.When you point it out and detail it..hear it.