From what I see on Google, Nigerian made his first post about Molly
watr on December 21st, 2012.
http://www.thecoli.com/threads/so-long-rat-race.71578/
Molly
water.com's trademark filing date is January 16th, 2013.
Difference of 26 days.
In November 2012, the month before, Nigerian was thinking about quitting work and starting a pornography website, so I doubt he had any intentions of Molly
watr before December.
http://www.thecoli.com/threads/dropping-everything-to-become-a-pornstar.58331/
If I was a betting man, I'd say in December...the Molly
water trademark had not been filed yet (obviously) but, the Molly
water.com website domain had already been bought. That's what I think
Conventional wisdom tells me that if any sane business person had the choice between the actual official sounding Mollywater.com domain or some offbrand sh*t like Mollywatr.com, they're not gonna choose the second one.
If you just wanted to spell it weird, and if you were really the first person, most people would have still bought both domains to protect their business name just in case, kinda like Facebook bought up various misspellings of their name. That's how I know Nigerian is full of sh*t
The official one wasn't available when Ken wanted to start his business because Sean was already moving at that point. So he dropped the "E" and thought since there was no trademark yet, he still had time to bring his to market first.