TheDarceKnight
Veteran
That's a good theory.Yeah - my theory is it didn't have the one classic, undeniable single to push it over the top. The Source review actually comes out and says this. No song as good as Shook Ones Pt 2, but they somehow managed to get better since the Infamous.
Also I like that it's their most self contained album out of their top 3. Infamous had Q-Tip production, and Murda Muzik had Alchemist production. Even Juvenile Hell had other producers and definitely their post Murda Muzik albums started adding way more additional producers. I think hell on Earth is the only album they've done that's all Havoc beats. He was on some shyt because Last Day and The Promise sound like they'd fit right at home on there. That one era of Havoc beats he's never really done before or since. This is maybe the closest he got.
Maybe The Infamous was just so unlike anything before that Hell on Earth wasn't as game changing? Good question. I think Infamous had more 10/10 songs, but every song on HOE is like a 9 at the very least.