Miguel Angel Cotto or Felix Tito Trinidad? Who has the better legacy? Who does PR love more?

RedBull

RedBull

All Star
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
3,992
Reputation
704
Daps
10,768
Reppin
On KRS One's nose, eating sunflower seeds.
Lets see:

Tito fought:

B Hop- loss
Oscar (undefeated) won
Sweet Pea- won
Roy Jones- loss
Fernando Vargas (undefeated)-won
Winky- loss
Mayorga- won
Joppy- won
David Reid (undefeated)-won
Oba Carr (undefeated)- won
Macho Camacho -won
Maurice Blocker- won

Cotto fought:

Margarito- won/ loss (cheated)
Sugar Shane- won
Floyd- loss
Zab- won
Trout- loss
Manny- loss
Chop Chop-won
Randall Bailey- won
Paulie Malignaggi (undefeated) won
Mayorga- won
Yuri Foreman (undefeated)-won
Joshua Clottey- won
Jennings (1loss)won
Quintana (undefeated) - won
Martinez- to be determined
 
ChocolateGiddyUp

ChocolateGiddyUp

Superstar
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
17,202
Reputation
2,062
Daps
43,674
Reppin
Chicago
RedBull said:
Lets see:

Tito fought:

B Hop- loss
Oscar (undefeated) won
Sweet Pea- won
Roy Jones- loss
Fernando Vargas (undefeated)-won
Winky- loss
Mayorga- won
Joppy- won
David Reid (undefeated)-won
Oba Carr (undefeated)- won
Macho Camacho -won
Maurice Blocker- won

Cotto fought:

Margarito- won/ loss (cheated)
Sugar Shane- won
Floyd- loss
Zab- won
Trout- loss
Manny- loss
Chop Chop-won
Randall Bailey- won
Paulie Malignaggi (undefeated) won
Mayorga- won
Yuri Foreman (undefeated)-won
Joshua Clottey- won
Jennings (1loss)won
Quintana (undefeated) - won
Martinez- to be determined
Click to expand...



I ain't counting losses in building your resume

Tito
Oscar (undefeated)
Vargas (undefeated)
David Reid (undefeated)
Yori Boy Campas (56-0 undefeated)
Oba Carr (undefeated)
Macho Camacho
Sweet Pea
Maurice Blocker
Joppy
Mayorga (never been knocked down)


Cotto:
Sugar Shane
Zab
Margarito
Paulie
Clottey
Mayorga

nikkas like Foreman, Bailey, Chop Chop, Jennings, Quintana is nothing special N can be found on any top fighters Resume

Tito is too strong up top for Cotto to fukk with N you cant play the take away the dlh W game cuz then we gotta look at Cottos Shane N Clottey W:youngsabo:

Titos losses came late in his career, against Elite fighters much bigger then him in weight classes he didn't belong in

Cottos losses were in his Prime N Prime weights...2 losses against smaller fighters N 2 losses against fighters he shoulda beat (trout N Margarito)


Throw in Titos accomplishments Jus for fun:shaq:
#2 P4P
15 welterweight title defenses
Unified at 147 & 154
 
RedBull

RedBull

All Star
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
3,992
Reputation
704
Daps
10,768
Reppin
On KRS One's nose, eating sunflower seeds.
ChocolateGiddyUp said:
I ain't counting losses in building your resume

Tito
Oscar (undefeated)
Vargas (undefeated)
David Reid (undefeated)
Yori Boy Campas (56-0 undefeated)
Oba Carr (undefeated)
Macho Camacho
Sweet Pea
Maurice Blocker
Joppy
Mayorga (never been knocked down)


Cotto:
Sugar Shane
Zab
Margarito
Paulie
Clottey
Mayorga

nikkas like Foreman, Bailey, Chop Chop, Jennings, Quintana is nothing special N can be found on any top fighters Resume

Tito is too strong up top for Cotto to fukk with N you cant play the take away the dlh W game cuz then we gotta look at Cottos Shane N Clottey W:youngsabo:

Titos losses came late in his career, against Elite fighters much bigger then him in weight classes he didn't belong in

Cottos losses were in his Prime N Prime weights...2 losses against smaller fighters N 2 losses against fighters he shoulda beat (trout N Margarito)


Throw in Titos accomplishments Jus for fun:shaq:
#2 P4P
15 welterweight title defenses
Unified at 147 & 154
Click to expand...

Let's not forget that Camacho and Sweet Pea were past their primes too.

Why do you keep telling me how Cotto can't fukk with Tito when I said the same thing? Calm down. I BEEN said Tito was better, I just was showing that Cotto's legacy is excellent. Breath......
 
King P

King P

Legends Never Die
Joined
Nov 12, 2012
Messages
15,502
Reputation
3,412
Daps
48,561
Reppin
Views From The X
RedBull said:
Then don't breh, it's just for conversation. Y'all gonna talk about Floyd in every thread?:yeshrug:
Click to expand...
:ehh: Fair enough

Tito by far. Not saying Cotto doesn't get love by PR, but he wasn't loved by them the way Tito was, both on the island and in the states. shyt, Cotto isn't even more popular than Camacho.

And for legacy, Tito easily. He's a Top 3-5 PR fighter ever. Cotto is Top 10, but he's not that high up on the list. He has a chance to move higher up on the list, especially if he beats Sergio. But I don't think he'll ever be on the level.

Like the homie @LauderdaleBoss once said...

LauderdaleBoss said:
Cotto would have to KO Martinez, and then KO GGG later this year and KO Canelo and Kirkland next year for me to even THINK about moving him ahead of Tito on the all time list. :what:
Click to expand...
 
ChocolateGiddyUp

ChocolateGiddyUp

Superstar
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
17,202
Reputation
2,062
Daps
43,674
Reppin
Chicago
RedBull said:
Let's not forget that Camacho and Sweet Pea were past their primes too.

Why do you keep telling me how Cotto can't fukk with Tito when I said the same thing? Calm down. I BEEN said Tito was better, I just was showing that Cotto's legacy is excellent. Breath......
Click to expand...


I don't see Cottos resume/legacy as all that

When Zab Judah is your 2nd best win we got a problem:russ:

Never beat any great champs, never been lineal champ, never unified, losses to average fighters:manny:
 
Walt

Walt

Veteran
Supporter
Hall of Fame
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
11,318
Reputation
12,069
Daps
69,466
Tuaminator said:
i know, a shame really..it was hard to fill in the void. tito was the el rey of PR boxing in the 90z..
Click to expand...

One of my close friends from P.R. still to this day has nights where he gets into some bourbon and pulls up youtube videos of Tito's fights and tears up a little. Tito was movin' the movement. People fukk with Cotto, but not like that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top