Microsoft vision for Xbox future on 15th February on the official Xbox podcast at 12pm PT. 3PM ET. 8pm GMT

Will Microsoft go full 3rd party and drop console hardware going forward?

  • Yes

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.

O³ (O cubed)

No more PAWGs, PLEASE??!!!??
Joined
Mar 8, 2017
Messages
16,553
Reputation
3,372
Daps
61,288
Reppin
Hackney, London
Case by case basis means just that

Case by case, y'all want them to commit to things that they aren't willing to because they aren't sure. Therefore games going to other platforms are case by case, which means they might start, stop and start again.
Phil is saying that to placate you. I remember when Quantum Break was released day and date on the PC. Phil said that going forwards PC releases will be a case by case basis
 
Last edited:

daze23

Siempre Fresco
Joined
Jun 25, 2012
Messages
31,772
Reputation
2,681
Daps
43,689
Phil is saying that to placate you. I remember when Quantum Break was released day and date on the PC. Phil said that going forwards PC releases will be a case by case basis
Spencer explains that Microsoft are “committed to bringing [the] biggest franchises from Xbox to Windows, we’ve said that” but that it “doesn’t mean, necessarily, that every game ends up on both platforms, because there could be some differences in how things play.”

sounds like they committed to bringing their games to PC, but left some wiggle room if certain games weren't ported for whatever reason

edit: yall bring up this quote like Phil was reassuring console players some games would remain exclusive to consoles. really it was a statement for PC Gamers, so they wouldn't say "b-b-but you promised..." if a certain game stayed on consoles
 
Last edited:

O³ (O cubed)

No more PAWGs, PLEASE??!!!??
Joined
Mar 8, 2017
Messages
16,553
Reputation
3,372
Daps
61,288
Reppin
Hackney, London
sounds like they committed to bringing their games to PC, but left some wiggle room if certain games weren't ported for whatever reason

edit: yall bring up this quote like Phil was reassuring console players some games would remain exclusive to consoles. really it was a statement for PC Gamers, so they wouldn't say "b-b-but you promised..." if a certain game stayed on consoles
So doublespeak and marketing talk. This is the issue SOME Xbox fans have with Phil Spencer.
 

Gizmo_Duck

blathering blatherskite!
Joined
Aug 15, 2018
Messages
71,575
Reputation
5,358
Daps
151,478
Reppin
Duckburg, NY

MeachTheMonster

YourFriendlyHoodMonster
Joined
May 24, 2012
Messages
68,182
Reputation
3,636
Daps
106,612
Reppin
Tha Land
Sony stan strategy is to remove context then play dumb.

I think as an industry right now, there's a lot of pressure on the industry... it's been growing for a long time, now people are looking for [new] ways to grow. Us as fans, as players of games, we just have to anticipate there's going to be more change in some of the traditional ways that games are built and distributed... that's going to change, it's going to change for all of us.

We're making these decisions for some specific reasons. We make every decision, really, with the long-term health of Xbox in mind. And long-term health of Xbox means a growing platform, our games performing, building the best platform for creators, reaching as many players as we can."

Full context these statements aren’t contradictory.

Y’all would rather be straight up lied to

Went from “not all games will come.

To “after two years”

To “after one year”

To “only multiplayer”
x.com

Less than a week later




But yall in here talmbout xbox tho :wow:
 

Gizmo_Duck

blathering blatherskite!
Joined
Aug 15, 2018
Messages
71,575
Reputation
5,358
Daps
151,478
Reppin
Duckburg, NY
Sony stan strategy is to remove context then play dumb.





Full context these statements aren’t contradictory.

Y’all would rather be straight up lied to

Went from “not all games will come.

To “after two years”

To “after one year”

To “only multiplayer”
x.com

Less than a week later




But yall in here talmbout xbox tho :wow:


I thought you put me on ignore :pachaha:
 

Gizmo_Duck

blathering blatherskite!
Joined
Aug 15, 2018
Messages
71,575
Reputation
5,358
Daps
151,478
Reppin
Duckburg, NY

There is no reversion possible now. Pandora's Box is open and Microsoft has demonstrated they are willing to share really any game that would have formerly been exclusive with even their oldest rivals like PlayStation. They are not simply going to walk that back and in some cases, like Call of Duty, they cannot walk that back. The same is true for Overwatch and Diablo at Blizzard, which of course aren't going to be stripped from PlayStation.
The strategy now has to be one of band-aid pulling. Go third party developer. Release everything on Xbox and PS5 at the same time, with of course, one main caveat, Xbox players get all these games on Game Pass day one. PlayStation players have to buy them. I think that's as good as you're going to get, given where things are now.

-

There is little point trying to crawl back toward Sony in console sales. What was previously a 2:1 ratio in Sony's favor as of late may be closer to 5:1, according to analysts. Even Phil Spencer admits there's just no competing on that front anymore.
It devalues the Xbox brand, but guess what? That's already happened. The Xbox community has become barely a community at all recently in the wake of these confusing PlayStation announcements. What was once the idea that Xbox was buying devs to revive the console and create a slate to compete with Sony's much-heralded first party studios is simply not happening. And again, there's no going back now.

-

Xbox is currently caught between three or four different strategies right now. It needs to be simplified:

- Release Xbox studio games on PS5 day one at full price.
- Release Xbox studio games day one of Game Pass for "free," with no confusing new tiers.
- Rely on the idea that the best place to play those Game Pass games is Xbox hardware, even if cloud streaming and (expensive) PCs make Game Pass playable elsewhere.
- Admit to yourself that you have sacrificed what once was a loyal community in the name of "we want everyone to play Xbox games as many places as possible" which has finally manifested in PlayStation releases. You won't win them back, it's done.
Is this a great path forward? No, but I would argue it's better than whatever the hell is going on now, which is a confusing mess, hurting the brand and upsetting players anyway, and a system that is trying to have it both ways when that's effectively no longer really possible.
 
Top