Just so we're clear
- Apple's been listening to and spying on us and is paying 95 million (pennies to them) for getting caught
- Meta admitted they were pressured to lie about and have influenced elections
- Google developed A.I. to identify and kill people
but Tik Tok is a national security threat and will be banned in 12 days.
Just so we're clear:
TikTok has been doing the first two as well. They log users keystrokes, access clipboard data, and abuse location tracking to surveil individuals, including journalists. They got caught spying on journalists from Forbes and the Financial Times.
They're also not transparent about how their content moderation works. They censor content critical of the Chinese government. They censored videos about the Hong Kong protests, the Uyghur genocide, on Taiwan independence, and on Tibet. They also tweak their algorithm to promote disinformation or influence public opinion about Russia and China. They did it early on during Russia's invasion of Ukraine too.
And not to sound alarmist, but it's obvious why they are seen as a national security threat being a company based in China after all. There's the fear that given how company ownership and the Chinese government relationship works, the government could compel them to hand over user data or force them to push even more blatant state-approved narratives. Do I support this? Not really, no. I think instead of singling out TikTok, we should go after every social medial platform that engages in such abuses, whether they're from the US or not. They have all mishandled user data and allowed foreign influence operations and disinformation campaigns on their platform. The concern should be about data privacy and transparency across ALL platforms, not just one. But I'm not naive.
Having said that, I don't support banning TikTok. That's not really a solution.