Meltzer Stinks!

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

Trick Williams defeated Carmelo Hayes – ***1/2 (3.5)

Wild

 

[Finn Baller]

He gave Cody / Reigns 4.75

Meanwhile:

United States AEW Dynamite #231
Mar 6th 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Kyle Fletcher***** (5.00)

United States AEW Revolution 2024
Mar 3rd 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Konosuke Takeshyta*****¾ (5.75)

United Kingdom RevPro High Stakes 2024: Ospreay Vs. Oku
Feb 18th 2024Michael Oku (C)Def. (Sub)Will OspreayRevPro British Heavyweight Title
****** (6.00)

United States TNA Impact #1017 Taping
Jan 14th 2024Josh AlexanderDef. (Pin)Will Ospreay*****½ (5.5)

United States NJPW Battle In The Valley 2024
Jan 13th 2024Kazuchika OkadaDef.Will Ospreay*****

other matches he gave the same rating as Cody/Roman, what a list of classics:

Adam Copeland vs Christian no DQ match
Lee Moriarty vs Lee Johnson vs Kyle Fletcher vs Kommander at some ROH PPV
Top Flight & Action Andretti vs Kommander, Penta, Vikingo on Rampage
Big Bill & Ricky Starks vs FTR vs Rush & Dralistico vs Brody King & Malakai Black ladder match
Will Ospreay & Sammy Guevara & Takeashyta vs Kenny Omega & Jericho & Kota Ibushi

 

[CBoz]

Wild

The Triple Threat was easily 5 stars, maybe even 6 with his scale.

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

other matches he gave the same rating as Cody/Roman, what a list of classics:

Adam Copeland vs Christian no DQ match
Lee Moriarty vs Lee Johnson vs Kyle Fletcher vs Kommander at some ROH PPV
Top Flight & Action Andretti vs Kommander, Penta, Vikingo on Rampage
Big Bill & Ricky Starks vs FTR vs Rush & Dralistico vs Brody King & Malakai Black ladder match
Will Ospreay & Sammy Guevara & Takeashyta vs Kenny Omega & Jericho & Kota Ibushi

Wtf

 

[Wolfpac]

other matches he gave the same rating as Cody/Roman, what a list of classics:

Adam Copeland vs Christian no DQ match
Lee Moriarty vs Lee Johnson vs Kyle Fletcher vs Kommander at some ROH PPV
Top Flight & Action Andretti vs Kommander, Penta, Vikingo on Rampage
Big Bill & Ricky Starks vs FTR vs Rush & Dralistico vs Brody King & Malakai Black ladder match
Will Ospreay & Sammy Guevara & Takeashyta vs Kenny Omega & Jericho & Kota Ibushi

Copeland vs Christian was a classic to be fair.

The other ones tho… the fukk lol

 

[Finn Baller]

Wtf

Copeland vs Christian was a classic to be fair.

The other ones tho… the fukk lol

That was a good match that low key saved the PPV but 4.75 used to mean something. Isn't that what he gave HBK vs Taker at WM25?

He also gave that MJF vs Jay White main event 4.5 stars

 

[Trips]

Ya'll can't take the Meltzer ratings bait Brehs. You know just being a WWE match it's going to start out at -0.5 on the Meltzer scale at least

 

[Thebadguy]

Dave responds to anybody

 

[Wolfpac]

dikk Drainers

 

[Brad Piff]

He gave Cody / Reigns 4.75

 

[Heelish]

He gave Cody / Reigns 4.75

Meanwhile:

United States AEW Dynamite #231
Mar 6th 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Kyle Fletcher***** (5.00)

United States AEW Revolution 2024
Mar 3rd 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Konosuke Takeshyta*****¾ (5.75)

United Kingdom RevPro High Stakes 2024: Ospreay Vs. Oku
Feb 18th 2024Michael Oku (C)Def. (Sub)Will OspreayRevPro British Heavyweight Title
****** (6.00)

United States TNA Impact #1017 Taping
Jan 14th 2024Josh AlexanderDef. (Pin)Will Ospreay*****½ (5.5)

United States NJPW Battle In The Valley 2024
Jan 13th 2024Kazuchika OkadaDef.Will Ospreay*****

I never took him seriously, but when I found out he didn’t give a 5 star match until he joined AEW, idk how his fans could defend him anymore. Guy is a joke

 

[OneDeep]

He gave Cody / Reigns 4.75

Meanwhile:

United States AEW Dynamite #231
Mar 6th 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Kyle Fletcher***** (5.00)

United States AEW Revolution 2024
Mar 3rd 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Konosuke Takeshyta*****¾ (5.75)

United Kingdom RevPro High Stakes 2024: Ospreay Vs. Oku
Feb 18th 2024Michael Oku (C)Def. (Sub)Will OspreayRevPro British Heavyweight Title
****** (6.00)

United States TNA Impact #1017 Taping
Jan 14th 2024Josh AlexanderDef. (Pin)Will Ospreay*****½ (5.5)

United States NJPW Battle In The Valley 2024
Jan 13th 2024Kazuchika OkadaDef.Will Ospreay*****

He rated a random six man tag on Rampage from a week or two ago the same as Roman vs Cody

 

[Finn Baller]

I never took him seriously, but when I found out he didn’t give a 5 star match until he joined AEW, idk how his fans could defend him anymore. Guy is a joke

clearly Bryan didn’t know how to work until Tony Khan sat him under the learning tree

 

[Brad Piff]

If only Kurt Angle would have had the guidance of the great Tony Khan

 

[Finn Baller]

Shawn Michaels and Undertaker in front of 70K people at Wrestlemania

Shawn Michaels and Undertaker in front of 3200 people on Dynamite