Meltzer Stinks!

[Brad Piff]

 

[Finn Baller]

"Hey guys, please don't watch Smackdown tonight, Daniel Bryan is wrestling a masked boomer in Mexico "

 

[Trips]

Dave kind of brought that one on himself. Like he had to know he was going to get cooked for that

 

[NoMorePie]

Lol

 

[Trips]

Dave should just go all in and only big up AEW and "report" on Japan, Mexico, the Indies and nothing WWE. He would honestly look better in the aftermath.

 

[Cattle Mutilation]

Dave should just go all in and only big up AEW and "report" on Japan, Mexico, the Indies and nothing WWE. He would honestly look better in the aftermath.

He doesn’t have a good track record with them anymore either.

He’s basically Fox News of wrestling reporting minus all the vitriol hate speech

 

[Cattle Mutilation]

 

[Finn Baller]

of course Meltzer's problem with that match wasn't that Hobbs shouldn't be taking more televised losses, but that his man crush Ospreay took too many bumps and made Hobbs look viable

 

[Heelish]

This has to be the first time Meltz has complained about an Ospreay match

 

[CBoz]

Not Meltz but just as bad. Triple H literally stated this before hand. Thanks Captain Obvious.

 

[Space Cowboy]

Not Meltz but just as bad. Triple H literally stated this before hand. Thanks Captain Obvious.

I wish they’d keep it. I fukking love that set

 

[Cattle Mutilation]

I wish they’d keep it. I fukking love that set

Reminds me a bit of a smaller version of what AEW ran for All In last year. Both are really good, though for someone like Gunther it takes away from his presentation a bit compared to the gigantic LED screens

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

He gave Cody / Reigns 4.75

Meanwhile:

United States AEW Dynamite #231
Mar 6th 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Kyle Fletcher***** (5.00)

United States AEW Revolution 2024
Mar 3rd 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Konosuke Takeshyta*****¾ (5.75)

United Kingdom RevPro High Stakes 2024: Ospreay Vs. Oku
Feb 18th 2024Michael Oku (C)Def. (Sub)Will OspreayRevPro British Heavyweight Title
****** (6.00)

United States TNA Impact #1017 Taping
Jan 14th 2024Josh AlexanderDef. (Pin)Will Ospreay*****½ (5.5)

United States NJPW Battle In The Valley 2024
Jan 13th 2024Kazuchika OkadaDef.Will Ospreay*****

 

[Cattle Mutilation]

He gave Cody / Reigns 4.75

Meanwhile:

United States AEW Dynamite #231
Mar 6th 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Kyle Fletcher***** (5.00)

United States AEW Revolution 2024
Mar 3rd 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Konosuke Takeshyta*****¾ (5.75)

United Kingdom RevPro High Stakes 2024: Ospreay Vs. Oku
Feb 18th 2024Michael Oku (C)Def. (Sub)Will OspreayRevPro British Heavyweight Title
****** (6.00)

United States TNA Impact #1017 Taping
Jan 14th 2024Josh AlexanderDef. (Pin)Will Ospreay*****½ (5.5)

United States NJPW Battle In The Valley 2024
Jan 13th 2024Kazuchika OkadaDef.Will Ospreay*****

All those matches were fukking amazing too though

At this point it has to be a bit of not giving WWE five stars though lol

 

[CBoz]

He gave Cody / Reigns 4.75

Meanwhile:

United States AEW Dynamite #231
Mar 6th 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Kyle Fletcher***** (5.00)

United States AEW Revolution 2024
Mar 3rd 2024Will OspreayDef. (Pin)Konosuke Takeshyta*****¾ (5.75)

United Kingdom RevPro High Stakes 2024: Ospreay Vs. Oku
Feb 18th 2024Michael Oku (C)Def. (Sub)Will OspreayRevPro British Heavyweight Title
****** (6.00)

United States TNA Impact #1017 Taping
Jan 14th 2024Josh AlexanderDef. (Pin)Will Ospreay*****½ (5.5)

United States NJPW Battle In The Valley 2024
Jan 13th 2024Kazuchika OkadaDef.Will Ospreay*****

He couldn't even give anything on Stand & Deliver 5 stars either.

Dave Meltzer’s Star Ratings For NXT Stand & Deliver Are As Follows:​

Pre-Show:

• Joe Gacy defeated Shawn Spears – **1/2 (2.5)

Main card:

• Baron Corbin and Bron Breakker defeated Axiom and Nathan Frazer to retain the Tag Team Championships – ****1/4 (4.25)
• Oba Femi defeated Dijak and Josh Briggs to retain the North American Championship – ****1/2 (4.5)
• Kelani Jordan, Fallon Henley and Thea Hail defeated Jacy Jayne, Kiana James and Izzi Dame – *** (3)
• Roxanne Perez defeated Lyra Valkyria to become the new NXT Women’s Champion – ***3/4 (3.75)
• Ilja Dragunov defeated Tony D’Angelo to retain the NXT Championship – ****1/4 (4.25)
• Trick Williams defeated Carmelo Hayes – ***1/2 (3.5)