Pierce has never been dominant. JORDAN???? He was the one of the most athletically gifted players the league had ever seen when he showed up.
As for my response to
@DPresidential - I deleted your LeBron points for the sake of cleanliness. LeBron has incredible physical tools, but also incredible control over those physical tools to go along with an upper-echelon understanding of the game. He's the best wing passer in the game. Great vision, great timing. He also uses a ton of angles on offense, along with the bullying that comes with his size/strength. He's also constantly getting smaller advantages, flopping is a great example... it drives people nuts, but it's small moves like that - that give him even more advantages beyond physical skills.
I don't know how to respond to "if he lost his athleticism" arguments, because if most of these guys "lose athleticism" they're no longer NBA players. Is the question "if he was only as athletic as paul pierce, would he dominate?" I don't know, Paul Pierce has never dominated... but he'd be a better passer, he'd be bigger and longer. He's a better shooter now, so he'd probably be a better shooter. He'd be better. You used Kobe, but even kobe from two years ago was WAY more athletic than Paul Pierce. You also used MJ... I don't even know how to respond to that, MJ was a freak.
I threw a lot of shade at you, probably undeserving. But the idea that the best player in the game right now "relies on his athleticism" is some real barbershop bullshyt.
As far as these points: I didn't say any of that. I only responded to the idea that LeBron relies on his athleticism. Could he depreciate? Sure. I think that if you look at how Melo's game is getting further and further from the hoop
(fewer dunks in the last 4 years than he had in 08 alone) - There are concerns that his game may not age well, either. People like to say "Kobe ages well because he's so skilled" well yes, but he's also still been an elite NBA athlete up until the last two years. Top 5-10%, easy. Same with Melo. It's not like Melo is Matt Harpring and still getting buckets. We're not talking about 35 year old Sabonis with no knees giving you 12/8.
So it as a gut reaction to your post.
I also wanted to do a little myth-busting about the whole "oh his game is going to age well" - I'm not so sure of that. He's already not a good defender. He's only going to get worse. His game is getting further from the hoop, his Finishing rate around the basket is down 2+% points EVERY season for the last 6 seasons. This year 3pts made up 40% of his shots. 40%! He's missing games... there are causes for concern.
So I jumped you on the LeBron shyt to make a point about the way you were talking about basketball more than just about you. We don't know each other, I'm sure we both want the team to be good. So no beef intended...
Just look at those numbers, and look at the player we might be signing a to a max deal.
I'm not totally sold I want those trends 2, 3, 4, 5 years from now... He's not opting out of this next deal.
Lj has great vision but his timing, accuracy, and ball-handling skills are atrocious. This is why he turns the ball over so much (3.5 to 'Melo's 2.5). Did you know his assists-to-bad pass-ratio is the same as Felton's? Lj plays PG and is the primary ball handler for his team (because he can't play off the ball) leading his team not only in usage, but touches, giving him more opportunities to have direct assists (as opposed to hockey assists); always has. Felton averages almost just as many for the same reason (6.5) and he was on
the Bobcats for most of his career. 'Melo has never been the primary ball-handler/facilitator for his team. It's always been guys like Billups, Baron, Jeremy, Felton, Pablo, etc. 'Melo doesn't lead his team in touches; Felton does because he's the PG. As someone on here once pointed out, let most people control the ball as much as him and they'll match his assist totals.
Lj is less than 50% from the field for his career. This is pathetic for a dunker/layup guy. That's an elite jump-shooter. He's gotten more efficient playing alongside Wade and Bosh, just as all 3 of them have gotten more efficient playing alongside one another. KD has gotten more efficient playing alongside Westbrook. In Lj's last season in Cleveland, he shot 45.1% from 5-9ft and it was only worse, the further he was from the basket. So, no, he's not a better shooter than Pierce. The biggest problem with this is that every year of his career, a large majority of his fga's came from within 5ft of the basket. Whatever will he do when he's no longer fast, athletic, and strong enough to drive like he can now against younger players?
'Melo's opponents shot over 40% in only 2 categories this season.
Who lit him up this season? Last season he ranked in the 69th %tile (a full 19% above average). He was excellent in defending the post up (his position [PF] last season) 92nd%tile. Lj's game will age better than 'Melo's?
What kind of athleticism does it take to shoot 46% from 15-19ft? 'Melo shoots at that clip from there. Ya boy is a pathetic 33.1% from there.
Lj is one of the worst defenders in the league.
When he gets settled in a half court defense, he is always looking for the ball and not always watching his guy. He gets beat off the dribble a
lot and his lateral movements are horrendous. In his off-ball defense, he often loses his man, and blames it on Chalmers. He's not a good on-ball defender, in fact he is quite terrible. He only defends in spurts and takes 2/3rds of games off. He doesn't shut anyone down. He stops moving/guarding someone, watches his opponents shoot the ball in and then looks down at one of his teammates to wonder what they were doing. I can give Youtube links of this, if you like, because the film don't lie.
Lj defends in transition at times. He'll roam around and make plays when he's out of position (or gambling) and he makes the flashy plays that everyone loves (steals, blocks), but when he has to face his opponent up, he's terrible. His steals be off bad passes. You never see him press someone and take their dribble. What you do see, is him play the passing lanes.
He can't defend anyone w/ talent. 'Melo and Durant be lighting him up for 30pts (Durant), 38-40+ pts and game-winners ('Melo). Beckly Mason noted in the 2012 finals:
"The tape shows Durant is hardly struggling in one-on-one confrontations with James. In fact, James has not been able to stay in front of Durant off the dribble and Durant has also been able to shoot with relative ease because James tends to play one-on-one defense with his hands low. Durant has missed some open shots, but for the most part he's getting the same looks he did against Battier". This was when Serge Ibaka said:
"LeBron is not a good defender. He can play defense for two to three minutes but not 48 minutes. LeBron can't play (Durant) one-on-one. They're playing good defense like a team".
KD shot poorly against 'Melo last season and the only reason he got 27 pts was from the free-throw line. Lj won't even shoot the ball when 'Melo is guarding him. That's 2 of the league's leading scorers. Lj can't do that and he said as much in the video below:
In this video, he claims that no one can guard KD but again, 'Melo sure did last season. Lj is so weak and soft that he won't even take on the challenge of defending people with size, like 'Melo and West. He lets Battier do it, even though he's much younger and bigger (he got like 20-lbs on battier).