People are forgetting that Eli DID get a lot of criticism for what happened on draft day. Yes, it wasn’t as much as what happened with Shedeur, but social media is 1,000 times more prevalent today. Add in the fact that Eli was the consensus first overall pick and didn’t have the same interview issues and antics leading up to the draft like Sabders, and other than looking at their situations on the surface, they aren’t the same.
If Shedeur was a Luck, Lawrence, or Caleb lever prospect, he would have gone first overall. NFL scouts and GM’s did NOT think he was as good as the MEDIA (need clicks) made him out to be. People let that impact their views as they keep thinking he was always going to be a top five pick or first round pick at worst. NFL teams clearly didn’t think so.
Now, is he a 5th round talent when compared to some of the other QB’s drafted and where they were drafted? Let’s say no, and that he’s better than some. If he’s not a first round talent, then teams might not want all of the extra stuff that will come with Shedeur if he isn’t going to be starting right away. You can deal with that with a franchise QB and top pick, but teams would rather not deal with the extra stuff if you’re not a sure fire stud in their minds.