UpAndComing
Veteran
5:55
Says that 9th Wonder was only the beatmaker, and not even for every song. And Phonte was the head Producer. Interesting
So why the hell does 9th Wonder get all the credit for these albums then?
Little Brother: 9th Wonder wasn't the real producer for our albums, Phonte was
- Thread starter UpAndComing
- Start date
5:55
Says that 9th Wonder was only the beatmaker, and not even for every song. And Phonte was the head Producer. Interesting
So why the hell does 9th Wonder get all the credit for these albums then?
KingsOfKings
♟️ GRANDMASTERS ♟️
And here we go.
Neo. The Only. The One.
THE ONE
I could see this. But let's see where it goes.
wait a second, what the fukk does this mean then
He's saying producer in Puffy terms. 9th made the beats, Phonte was the one creating the concepts and figuring out how to develop the songs.wait a second, what the fukk does this mean then
Mindfield333
Superstar
Beat maker = making beatswait a second, what the fukk does this mean then
Producer = Album sequencing, Format of the beats, ideas, skits etc.
UpAndComing
Veteran
wait a second, what the fukk does this mean then
In the music hierarchy, a beatmaker is below a Producer
A beatmaker is the ones who makes the beats
A Producer is the one who is in charge of the entire song structure, rearranging, and may even be the ones who also pick the sample
Piff Perkins
Veteran
I've largely sided with them but this is going too far.
Jayou Ayen
All Star
Whoever picked the snares, that’s the most important breh in the group.
Same fukking snares on every song.
39
Same fukking snares on every song.
39
This is unnecessary stratification.
9th is a producer.
9th is a producer.
Bloodclaut
The problem is the language we are using.
Producer. That's a word. Good words mean certain things, not one of a few things that are unclear.
Calling a beat maker a producer might be the problem with how we see all this.
If Puff is a producer, then it's okay for 9th to not be a producer.
I don't respect Puff over Easy Mo Bee for the tracks Mo Bee made for Bad Boy.
When I found out Rakim made his own beats, I lost any respect for Eric B.
QTip and Scarface make beats. That's impressive to me. I don't give a fukc who the studio engineer was.
Who "produced" Illmatic as a whole? Who gives a shyt? He had the top beat makers on there.
Producer. That's a word. Good words mean certain things, not one of a few things that are unclear.
Calling a beat maker a producer might be the problem with how we see all this.
If Puff is a producer, then it's okay for 9th to not be a producer.
I don't respect Puff over Easy Mo Bee for the tracks Mo Bee made for Bad Boy.
When I found out Rakim made his own beats, I lost any respect for Eric B.
QTip and Scarface make beats. That's impressive to me. I don't give a fukc who the studio engineer was.
Who "produced" Illmatic as a whole? Who gives a shyt? He had the top beat makers on there.
UpAndComing
Veteran
I don't understand that analogy. Puff is neither a beatmaker or a producer
And Easy Mo Bee is both a beatmaker and Producer
