You're welcome to try. That's your opinion though, I doubt you'd be able to get that large a consensus of guys above Kurt.
If your criteria is only US wrestlers that worked in mainstream promotions in the last 20 years, then yeah, Kurt has a very strong case for top 5. That's why the concensus is that's he's one of the GOATs as not a lot of people feel the need to watch an insane amount of wrestling, and there's nothing wrong with that.
But there's a shyt ton wrestling out there, you gotta be really fukking good to be top 5 if you watch a good chunk of it.
On a poll taken by the nerdiest wrestling nerds this year- were people took into account japan, mexico, england and a shyt ton of pre-90's wrestling - Kurt Angle was ranked 68
My top 5 all time list would be
Jumbo Tsuruta
Bret Hart
Randy Savage
WCW era Rick Rude
Arn Anderson
In no particular order. I'm sure you can see why Kurt wouldn't be on my list of top 5. He'd def be in my top 30, though.
WCW Rick Rude lasted like 4 years. That's enough for top 5 ALL TIME?