Joe Montana calls Marino the BOAT qb

[premier58]

If you think there are lots of other quarterbacks on Marino’s level based on “eye test” then your eye test is terrible.

Brainwashed bullshyt..this isnt 1990. All these guys are his equals in terms of eyes test. Favre, Manning, Brady, Rodgers and Mahomes. Why Marino win one lone MVP, yet you guys act like he was the Gretzky or Bonds of the NFL?

 

[Bboystyle]

You also failed to mention that after his 48 td seasons, he went down to 30.

again, name a QB who did better during his era in TD stats? no one. Not even Montana. I dont get this argument you having here?

 

[NYC Rebel]

Marino wasn’t even better than Jim Kelly

 

[Lord-Yosh]

Brady is the goat because of achievements. Peyton Manning is the best QB to ever play in the NFL so far

 

[Bboystyle]

Brainwashed bullshyt..this isnt 1990. All these guys are his equals in terms of eyes test. Favre, Manning, Brady, Rodgers and Mahomes. Why Marino win one lone MVP, yet you guys act like he was the Gretzky or Bonds of the NFL?

and this is where the convo ends. Those two are not on Marino's level talent/passing wise based off of eye test.

 

[NYC Rebel]

Brainwashed bullshyt..this isnt 1990. All these guys are his equals in terms of eyes test. Favre, Manning, Brady, Rodgers and Mahomes. Why Marino win one lone MVP, yet you guys act like he was the Gretzky or Bonds of the NFL?

What eye testi you talking about? None of those guys are good a Passer as Marino.

None.

 

[Bboystyle]

Marino wasn’t even better than Jim Kelly

stick to baseball.. nah scratch that, log off and never return

 

[Remote]

Brainwashed bullshyt..this isnt 1990. All these guys are his equals in terms of eyes test. Favre, Manning, Brady, Rodgers and Mahomes. Why Marino win one lone MVP, yet you guys act like he was the Gretzky or Bonds of the NFL?

You think accolades is what defines a player.

It’s not even worth discussing when you have such a strange way to define greatness or ability.

 

[premier58]

Well if eye test is what u want then he passes that with flying colors. How he aint in your top 3 off eye test alone is beyond me.

I never said he didnt pass the eye test, i said others have passed him since then. Bob Gibson was once the standard for outstanding pitching, Pedro passed him. Just like Randy Johnson became the best LHP passing off top who? Warren Spahn?

 

[Bboystyle]

I never said he didnt pass the eye test, i said others have passed him since then. Bob Gibson was once the standard for outstanding pitching, Pedro passed him. Just like Randy Johnson became the best LHP passing off top who? Warren Spahn?

What part of the pitching game changed during eras though? Marino did it during a time where defenses had a major advantage where as guys like Rodgers, Brady, and Mahomes play in a soft ass era where people like Stafford can throw for 5k+ yards and 30+ TDs easily.

Theres context my guy

 

[Cladyclad]

Brainwashed bullshyt..this isnt 1990. All these guys are his equals in terms of eyes test. Favre, Manning, Brady, Rodgers and Mahomes. Why Marino win one lone MVP, yet you guys act like he was the Gretzky or Bonds of the NFL?

Dudes watched a few highlights and think that shyt.

60 picks in 3 years is nuts to me

 

[Cladyclad]

What part of the pitching game changed during eras though? Marino did it during a time where defenses had a major advantage where as guys like Rodgers, Brady, and Mahomes play in a soft ass era where people like Stafford can throw for 5k+ yards and 30+ TDs easily.

Theres context my guy

What about Farve? 3 straight mvps 9 30 td seasons

 

[premier58]

You think accolades is what defines a player.

It’s not even worth discussing when you have such a strange way to define greatness or ability.

What? Film. Marinos film is no more impressive than the guys I mentioned. Youre just rigid and stuck in the past. Why shouldnt accolades matter too?? I could put on a highlight tape of Bert Jones throwing darts..or even a Rex Grossman..why shouldnt there awards matter? John Elway made some of the most awe inspiring throws, ever. Am I supposed to ignore his shytty seasons, his weak MVP year and never being 1st team All Pro.

 

[Black White Sox Hat]

Not the greatest decision maker when the game is on the line but I could watch him throw the football all day.N/h.

 

[premier58]

You think accolades is what defines a player.

It’s not even worth discussing when you have such a strange way to define greatness or ability.

So accolades dont matter?