Not this low-quality posting.
Head-to-head is meaningless when judging two players who
don't have hardly anything to do with each other.
Kobe didn't "kill" Duncan, and he didn't guard Duncan. He made shots against whatever scrubs were in the game guarding him.
Since you must have been 14-15 or so when this transpired, let me give you a little education.
1. From 1999-2005 when their teams met five times, the best two players in the game were Shaq and Duncan. They combined for three MVPs and SIX Finals MVPs in that stretch. They were dominant.
2. Shaq and Duncan didn't always guard each other, but they were the two dominant forces in the middle that both teams were centered around. It was always a Shaq vs. Duncan fight.
3. Phil Jackson's defensive strategy was to load up on Duncan, because the Spurs had almost nothing that didn't start with him. In the five years they faced the Lakers, there were ZERO other Spurs in the all-star game. Not one other all-star on the whole team.
4. Pop's strategy was to load up on Shaq and leave a defender on an island against Kobe. The hope was to goad Kobe into shooting 30-40 shots, because every shot Kobe took at 40-45% was one less shot that Shaq got to take at 60%. That's why Kobe has so many ridiculous volume shooting nights against the Spurs - it was the Spurs only chance of winning since they were always outmanned trying to pit Duncan and a bunch of role players against the Shaq/Kobe combo. The most beautiful example of that was 2003, where Kobe took FIFTY-SEVEN more shots than Shaq, straight shooting the Lakers out of the series even though Shaq was averaging 25-14-4-3 on 56% shooting (but only got 17 shots/game) while Duncan didn't have a single guy on his team averaging even 15ppg.
5. Yeah, some years Kobe made the shots, and some years he didn't. But he wasn't the "best player in the series." Kobe was going one-on-one while Duncan and Shaq were constantly double-teamed and schemed around. Even in some of the years he lost (look at 2002) it was clearly Duncan who was the best player on the court, and even when the Lakers won it was still Shaq carrying them as late as 2004. Kobe took way more shots, but far less efficiently and Shaq was much more important on defense.
6. You know why Duncan doesn't have a better head-to-head against Kobe? Because they ONLY played in the years when Duncan didn't have an elite supporting cast. Where was Kobe in 2005? 2006? 2007? 2012? 2013? 2014? If the Lakers had played Duncan's teams any of those six years, they would have gotten washed. But they sucked so bad they didn't even make it there.
That's one of the biggest differences between Duncan's teams and Kobe's teams. Even when Duncan's teams were crap (like 2001 when the #2 was Derek Anderson and only 3 Spurs averaged double figures, or 2007 when Ginobli was hurt and half the top-8 in the rotation were over 35 and ready to retire), the Spurs still made the WCF to face the Lakers. But when Kobe didn't have a massive supporting cast, he dipped out too early to even see the Spurs.
Your head-to-head comparison is a joke. They played in the same era and Duncan led his team to more titles than Kobe. You don't get extra credit for having the greatest center in the game to neutralize your opponent, or for only getting to face him in the years your team is elite.
What kind of nonsensical crap is that? How do you determine those peaks?
1999 Kobe when he didn't even average 20ppg was "peak" Kobe?
You have Kobe failing to get get past the first round FOUR TIMES in his "peak."
Kobe made 11 first-team All-NBAs and Duncan made 10 of them. The difference is ONE. And that's only cause Duncan finished four years of college first - put him in the NBA in 1997 and he probably makes 1st-team All-NBA that year just like he did in 1998 and ends up tied with Kobe.
And once again,
they don't face each other. Who was Kobe's biggest competition to make the All-NBA team? Some of those years he just had to beat out an injured Wade or an older Nash. Meanwhile, Duncan was listed at the forward spot where Garnett, McGrady, Lebron, Dirk, and later Durant were ALL fighting for those two first-team slots.
And he still got there ten times.