What do you consider elite, 20 & 10
do you think Gasol was elite 2011-14?
I'd say that outplaying the other team's best player in the Finals man-to-man makes you elite. Especially if you do it in back-to-back years.
Gasol straight up beat Dwight Howard and Kevin Garnett in back-to-back Finals. He wasn't just on the winning side, he was matched up against the other team's best player and outplayed them straight-up both times. THAT is elite.
Gasol was easily a top-3 two-way big during those runs. Only big who was clearly above him 2008-2010 was Duncan. KG was on the same level as Pau, Dwight showed that offensively he couldn't match him when it mattered.
A skilled all star reserve that can't carry a team and is best served in a supporting role
Pau carried a sorry-ass Grizzlies team to the playoffs 3 straight years when he was in just his 2nd/3rd/4th seasons in the league and his #2 option was James Posey, then Mike Miller.
And he wasn't just an "all-star reserve", he was All-NBA four times. Made 2nd-team All-NBA in 2011 (more votes than Amare, LMA, Blake, Love, Duncan, Bosh, and Carmelo) and then made another All-NBA team in 2015 and All-Star teams in '15/'16.