Is wolverine a better fighter than Captain America? ( Marvel rates capt fight skill 6 wolvie 7)

[Tryna Makit]

I don't really count it as healing factor unless you can grow back a severed limb like Wolverine and Deadpool. Wolverine has been torn in half and beheaded and still healed. Cap can't do that.

I know that wolverines healing factor outpaces caps my at least 10x (fitting, being weapon 1 and 10 respectively) but cap has that Batman plot armor that makes his superhuman feats push the validity of his peak human designation. Wolverine should win on paper....but on actual comic paper for some reason Cap is usually beatin his ass.
...for a more accurate comparison comic heads need to get some panels of fighters both have fought and figure out who had a better showing

 

[Mr. Negative]

If it came down to straight hands. . . I am not sure. I think Shang is superior in technique barely maybe. . But Cap has the advantage with the overall physical advantage and can simply wear him down over time. I do not think Shang would be able to knock him out before he gets to tired.


If we add in Cap's shield then I think its too much for Shang to overcome. You have a guy who is maybe a c*nt hair less skilled than you. But is stronger and more durable and has a shield that can hurt you.

I remember when they sparred lightly.

yeah, it's really just Cap's stats, IMO.

Sorta like Deathstroke being a complete beast, but prolly only has Frank Castle's martial art prowess, unless you count that Natas/Green Arrow shyt

 

[R=G]

Wolverine is deadlier but he isnt a better fighter than Captain America. Captain America always gets the job done..when Thanos kicked everyone's ass originally, he was the last one standing. Wolverine having that healing factor is his saving grace in most situations.

 

[Luke Cage]

I know that wolverines healing factor outpaces caps my at least 10x (fitting, being weapon 1 and 10 respectively) but cap has that Batman plot armor that makes his superhuman feats push the validity of his peak human designation. Wolverine should win on paper....but on actual comic paper for some reason Cap is usually beatin his ass.
...for a more accurate comparison comic heads need to get some panels of fighters both have fought and figure out who had a better showing

I never knew Cap was Weapon 1. He was part of the Weapon X program? When did this happen?

 

[Copy Ninja]

Different type of fighting styles.

Logan fights recklessly because he's got healing factor.

Cap is more technical.

In the long run, Wolvie should be able to beat Cap in a fight if we're being logical.

 

[General Mills]

Different type of fighting styles.

Logan fights recklessly because he's got healing factor.

Cap is more technical.

In the long run, Wolvie should be able to beat Cap in a fight if we're being logical.

Your right. If the fight goes for a long length of time then logically Wolvie should win. All Cap has to do is slip up once and those claws are doing real damage. Cap can hit Wolvie with his shield a hundred times and he will eat them shyts.


Plus one thing I tend to forget is that that Admantium skeleton probably hits hard as hell. A punch or kick by Wolvie has something extra on it.

 

[The axe murderer]

Panther isn't really street level anymore and Daredevil has stalemated Cap at least once.

I think Daredevil can be underrated too. He's given Spidey problems

 

[Mr. Negative]

I never knew Cap was Weapon 1. He was part of the Weapon X program? When did this happen?

during Morrison's run

 

[The axe murderer]

If it came down to straight hands. . . I am not sure. I think Shang is superior in technique barely maybe. . But Cap has the advantage with the overall physical advantage and can simply wear him down over time. I do not think Shang would be able to knock him out before he gets to tired.


If we add in Cap's shield then I think its too much for Shang to overcome. You have a guy who is maybe a c*nt hair less skilled than you. But is stronger and more durable and has a shield that can hurt you.

I remember when they sparred lightly.

Can't wait for shang chi
Mcu needs that Kung Fu goodness

 

[NormanConnors]

reasoning: You'll see websites and such list Wolvie as a better Hand to hand combatant and cite his age and travels as a reason for it

And true, Logan is 100+ years old and well traveled.



But Cap's brain is a living computer. He masters martial arts disciplines damn near the moment he uses/sees/tries them.

He's mastered every martial art ever shown to him. This includes martial arts from the future while dealing with Kang fukkery.

Plus he's FAR more experienced, having been stuck in different dimensions for decades at a time and being stuck in time loops/cosmic cubes for hundreds of years.

Hell, Cap has beaten Logan more than once.

He's beaten somebody who knew every martial art known to man (up to that time)

He's beaten DC Comics' Prometheus in a few panels, the same Prometheus who was writer Grant Morrison's version of "Anti-Batman" and had spent 2 or 3 issues beating the shyt out of the Justice League.


The stuff that Wolverine has over Cap are his healing factor and the adamatium.

I'm pretty sure Cap would say he dealt with some Nazi-ish Wolverine clone during WWII.


It's like this. Marvel "Street Level": Steve Rogers is at the top.

Below that, you got Black Panther (tied), Logan, Shang Chi, Iron Fist, Daredevil, Elekra, Black Widow, Moon Knight, Gambit, and obscure folks I'm sure only nerds have heard of.


Above Cap, you got Spider-Man.

, it's a stretch to say he's giving Daredevil that work too like THAT.

 

[Yaboysix]

reasoning: You'll see websites and such list Wolvie as a better Hand to hand combatant and cite his age and travels as a reason for it

And true, Logan is 100+ years old and well traveled.



But Cap's brain is a living computer. He masters martial arts disciplines damn near the moment he uses/sees/tries them.

He's mastered every martial art ever shown to him. This includes martial arts from the future while dealing with Kang fukkery.

Plus he's FAR more experienced, having been stuck in different dimensions for decades at a time and being stuck in time loops/cosmic cubes for hundreds of years.

Hell, Cap has beaten Logan more than once.

He's beaten somebody who knew every martial art known to man (up to that time)

He's beaten DC Comics' Prometheus in a few panels, the same Prometheus who was writer Grant Morrison's version of "Anti-Batman" and had spent 2 or 3 issues beating the shyt out of the Justice League.


The stuff that Wolverine has over Cap are his healing factor and the adamatium.

I'm pretty sure Cap would say he dealt with some Nazi-ish Wolverine clone during WWII.


It's like this. Marvel "Street Level": Steve Rogers is at the top.

Below that, you got Black Panther (tied), Logan, Shang Chi, Iron Fist, Daredevil, Elekra, Black Widow, Moon Knight, Gambit, and obscure folks I'm sure only nerds have heard of.

Above Cap, you got Spider-Man.

Bruh...you saying Spiderman got better hands than captain America!?..spidey sense dont equate to hands lol.

 

[Neuromancer]

Also I guess We're not counting this fight? Where Logan clearly almost killed Steve?

 

[Luke Cage]

Also I guess We're not counting this fight? Where Logan clearly almost killed Steve?

I can usually tell be the art whether or not it's a good or a badly written story. They always give the best writers the best artists. That said, this one isn't quite up the standards .

There been so many runs and alternate universes over the years, I only count the good ones. in most of those cap simply uses his superior tactics and cool headedness to outsmart logan and defeats him pretty easily everytime. like in this ultimates universe run. Fight lasted two seconds.

 

[Neuromancer]

I can usually tell be the art whether or not it's a good or a badly written story. They always give the best writers the best artists. That said, this one isn't quite up the standards .

There been so many runs and alternate universes over the years, I only count the good ones. in most of those cap simply uses his superior tactics and cool headedness to outsmart logan and defeats pretty easily. like in this ultimates universe run. Fight lasted two seconds.

I've read alot of stories with good art and shyt story. Civil War 2 comes to mind. And Steve Dillon co-created Preacher with this same art. So idk if that is a good assessment.

 

[Luke Cage]

I've read alot of stories with good art and shyt story. Civil War 2 comes to mind. And Steve Dillon co-created Preacher with this same art. So idk if that is a good assessment.

Maybe, it can happen in that case, but they never give a great writer a shytty artist.