Is Mike Tyson a consensus Top10 Heavyweight of All Time or no?

CSquare43

Superstar
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
14,881
Reputation
10,198
Daps
53,717
the internet is a funny place

I cant even IMAGINE :mindblown: this question even being ASKED in person why/how this clown is still allowed to created threads here...

Fixed.

:russ:

On the real though, if you lived through Mike's career, you probably wouldn't be asking this question.....Mike was vicious...
 

Rekkapryde

GT, LWO, 49ERS, BRAVES, HAWKS, N4O...yeah UMAD!
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
150,125
Reputation
27,402
Daps
505,352
Reppin
TYRONE GA!
I did some Googling and EVERYONE's list has him top 8-10. Couldnt find one that didnt and those people live off Covering the sport.

heavyweights-chart1.jpg

Holyfield and Lennox below him doesn't make a lick of sense.

@krackdagawd @patscorpio ????
 

MJ Truth

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 1, 2015
Messages
38,130
Reputation
3,435
Daps
151,759
Yes, he's top 10. I don't want to make excuses but he was robbed of years in his prime and he was never going to be the same after that. He never was. He was still a tough muthafukka and could beat most heavyweights but you can't lose years like that and then expect to beat Evander and Lewis.

He was wasting his talents prior to the Douglas fight tho. death hit him hard out here drinking and fukking whores not giving a fukk... probably got robbed in the fight too, Douglas was down for 10 :manny:
Intentions and potential don't matter in life, it's about your results. With Tyson it's always a lot of shoulda, coulda, woulda talk.
 

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
80,036
Reputation
24,363
Daps
362,303
In terms of overall body of work, if he did rank top 10 it would probably be 10th. I could see people leaving him just outside that level.

In terms of his skills and ferocity and dominance? Easily top 10.

Mike Tyson is arguably one of the top 5 or 10 most interesting athletes of the last century, period. There’s a reason why so many people still are interested in him decades after his prime.
 

Kunty McPhuck

Scust Szn has Returned
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
32,825
Reputation
3,512
Daps
64,540
Reppin
Books and Pencils
1/22/1986 Trevor Berbick Win TKO, 2
9/06/1986 Alfonzo Ratliff Win TKO, 2
8/17/1986 Jose Ribalta Win TKO, 10
7/26/1986 Marvis Frazier Win KO, 1
7/11/1986 Lorenzo Boyd Win KO, 2
6/28/1986 William Hosea Win KO, 1
6/13/1986 Reggie Gross Win TKO, 1
5/20/1986 Mitch Green Win UD, 10
5/03/1986 James Tillis Win UD, 10
3/10/1986 Steve Zouski Win KO, 3
2/16/1986 Jesse Ferguson Win TKO, 6
1/24/1986 Mike Jameson Win TKO, 5
1/11/1986 David Jaco Win TKO, 1
12/27/1985 Mark Young Win TKO, 1
12/06/1985 Sammy Scaff Win TKO, 1
11/22/1985 Conroy Nelson Win TKO, 2
11/13/1985 Eddie Richardson Win KO, 1
11/01/1985 Sterling Benjamin Win TKO, 1
10/25/1985 Robert Colay Win KO, 1
10/09/1985 Donnie Long Win TKO, 1
9/05/1985 Michael Johnson Win KO, 1
8/15/1985 Lorenzo Canady Win KO, 1
7/19/1985 Larry Sims Win KO, 3
7/11/1985 John Alderson Win RTD, 2
6/20/1985 Ricardo Spain Win TKO, 1
5/23/1985 Don Halpin Win KO, 4
4/10/1985 Trent Singleton Win TKO, 1
3/06/1985 Hector Mercedes Win TKO, 1

This is his run up to winning a title. Who are these nikkas.. everyone after up to losing to buster was shook. They fought for the payday. They didnt go in trying to win. Big difference..after Douglas he saw more and more tough fights against good fighters not great fighters good ones. Because that aura was burst by Douglas. Against Holyfield and Lewis he was food. Those are the only top ten heavyweights he faced.

Mitch Green is more famous for getting beating up outside of the ring by Tyson then in it.
 

Antdrewjosh

All Star
Joined
Oct 17, 2015
Messages
1,476
Reputation
333
Daps
5,287
Reppin
joshua1012
Mitch Green is more famous for getting beating up outside of the ring by Tyson then in it.

He wasnt scared by the Aura of mike either and you see that shyt went ten. He sucked as a fighter but not being scared let him stay in the fight for ten. And he wasnt just holding and running
 

Kunty McPhuck

Scust Szn has Returned
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
32,825
Reputation
3,512
Daps
64,540
Reppin
Books and Pencils
He wasnt scared by the Aura of mike either and you see that shyt went ten. He sucked as a fighter but not being scared let him stay in the fight for ten. And he wasnt just holding and running

It only took nearly 7 years for Green to get back into the ring after the Tyson fight
 

THE MACHINE

night owl
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
26,877
Reputation
6,520
Daps
104,343
Reppin
P.G. County
Holyfield and Lennox below him doesn't make a lick of sense.

@krackdagawd @patscorpio ????
As a heavyweight it makes sense, but all-time p4p Evander has to be ahead of him. Evander started out as a cruiser and had a great career there before moving up so his HW resume isnt quite as strong. Even though its still very very close.
 

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
80,036
Reputation
24,363
Daps
362,303
1/22/1986 Trevor Berbick Win TKO, 2
9/06/1986 Alfonzo Ratliff Win TKO, 2
8/17/1986 Jose Ribalta Win TKO, 10
7/26/1986 Marvis Frazier Win KO, 1
7/11/1986 Lorenzo Boyd Win KO, 2
6/28/1986 William Hosea Win KO, 1
6/13/1986 Reggie Gross Win TKO, 1
5/20/1986 Mitch Green Win UD, 10
5/03/1986 James Tillis Win UD, 10
3/10/1986 Steve Zouski Win KO, 3
2/16/1986 Jesse Ferguson Win TKO, 6
1/24/1986 Mike Jameson Win TKO, 5
1/11/1986 David Jaco Win TKO, 1
12/27/1985 Mark Young Win TKO, 1
12/06/1985 Sammy Scaff Win TKO, 1
11/22/1985 Conroy Nelson Win TKO, 2
11/13/1985 Eddie Richardson Win KO, 1
11/01/1985 Sterling Benjamin Win TKO, 1
10/25/1985 Robert Colay Win KO, 1
10/09/1985 Donnie Long Win TKO, 1
9/05/1985 Michael Johnson Win KO, 1
8/15/1985 Lorenzo Canady Win KO, 1
7/19/1985 Larry Sims Win KO, 3
7/11/1985 John Alderson Win RTD, 2
6/20/1985 Ricardo Spain Win TKO, 1
5/23/1985 Don Halpin Win KO, 4
4/10/1985 Trent Singleton Win TKO, 1
3/06/1985 Hector Mercedes Win TKO, 1

This is his run up to winning a title. Who are these nikkas.. everyone after up to losing to buster was shook. They fought for the payday. They didnt go in trying to win. Big difference..after Douglas he saw more and more tough fights against good fighters not great fighters good ones. Because that aura was burst by Douglas. Against Holyfield and Lewis he was food. Those are the only top ten heavyweights he faced.
This is such a lazy ass way to judge a boxer.
Who cares about his run up to the title?
They aren’t known because he destroyed them all. That’s the same story for just about every great fighter ever.
Who was Roy Jones fighting before his first title? You wanna look at that list?

You’re talking about Tyson being exposed after his loss to Douglas as if there weren’t a shyt ton of factors that affected Mike Tyson post-Cus and post-Jim Jacobs.

And I know.
“Bbbbut y’all making excuses”

No jackass. It’s about adding context.
 

Antdrewjosh

All Star
Joined
Oct 17, 2015
Messages
1,476
Reputation
333
Daps
5,287
Reppin
joshua1012
This is such a lazy ass way to judge a boxer.
Who cares about his run up to the title?
They aren’t known because he destroyed them all. That’s the same story for just about every great fighter ever.
Who was Roy Jones fighting before his first title? You wanna look at that list?

You’re talking about Tyson being exposed after his loss to Douglas as if there weren’t a shyt ton of factors that affected Mike Tyson post-Cus and post-Jim Jacobs.

And I know.
“Bbbbut y’all making excuses”

No jackass. It’s about adding context.


Um Roy went on to fight other great fighters and won.. so his leadup doesnt matter one bit. Mikes does because thats what all his dikkriders want to use to to show his greatness. His Prime. The Cus years..

fukk the factors everybody has issues Ali had issues he didnt fight for 5 years and still after fought other great fighters and won.. so kill the excuses. Especially excuses that were due to his own immaturity.
 

seemorecizzy

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,395
Reputation
2,351
Daps
52,960
Reppin
NULL
Top 3 boxing talent of all time
Id probably put him as the 10th all time heavyweight if we talking about resumes, opponents, durability etc..
 
Top