Is Mike Evans A HOF Player?

[premier58]

I am firmly a person who believes peak and prime are more important than longevity. I don’t get how people value longevity more than a high peak and prime. It is absolutely absurd.

I agree. Im with the Sayers, Campbells, Sharpes, Davis's etc...

 

[yseJ]

No,

I’m not too fixated on that. It’s much more important than compiling stats for 15+ years.

There is no universe where Gore should make the HOF. It would absolutely leave a stain if he were inducted.

The HOF should be for the elite, not the very good compilers

You’re better than this.

Once again. You trying to pass off opinions as facts. You believe this? Great. I don't. Don't try to tell me your opinion is better than mine.


Gore and Evans will be in HoF.
Craig Biggio is in baseball HoF. Was he ever a top five player?


It doesn't leave any stain whatsoever on HoF that people with career stats that are in top 3/5/10 of their position all time will get indicted.

 

[premier58]

I am firmly a person who believes peak and prime are more important than longevity. I don’t get how people value longevity more than a high peak and prime. It is absolutely absurd.

I forgot about Tiki. Another RB who was better than Frank.

 

[BucciMane]

Once again. You trying to pass off opinions as facts. You believe this? Great. I don't. Don't try to tell me your opinion is better than mine.


Gore and Evans will be in HoF.
Craig Biggio is in baseball HoF. Was he ever a top five player?


It doesn't leave any stain whatsoever on HoF that people with career stats that are in top 3/5/10 of their position all time will get indicted.

Again,

You believe very good stat compilers are worthy of the highest honor. That is absurd, and I disagree.

It’s fine that you don’t think elite and good mean different things.

 

[BucciMane]

@premier58


One of the few that truly knows what they are talking about.

 

[premier58]

@premier58


One of the few that truly knows what they are talking about.

Thanks, man. Likewise, my G.

 

[Shadow King]

MVP is a glorified best QB award. Matt Ryan aint shyt and had the worst choke job in a superbowl
like i said mike evans has been all pro twice but who cares. you probably dont think Eli Manning is a hall of famer for the same reason but guess what, he will be

on any given time there can be 2-5 receivers on the field compared to 1 QB. It is much harder to make all-pro for WR than it is for QBs as a result. Do your googles...everyone knows Mike Evans will be a HOF. I dont make the rules but he will be.

This is false. Less QBs means there's only 1 on each team, especially since they refuse to give an non-QB the MVP. First Team All-Pro QB = MVP.

 

[KING WILL]

Is Mike Evans a HOF player?

I value peak and prime over longevity,

but he's put up great numbers every year for a decade.

20 pages later, and the question was answered on the 1st post, by the thread starter.

Peak, Prime, and Longevity.

Great numbers over a decade.

 

[Shadow King]

He's getting in. Deal with it.

 

[yseJ]

Again,

You believe very good stat compilers are worthy of the highest honor. That is absurd, and I disagree.

It’s fine that you don’t think elite and good mean different things.

OK let's agree to disagree. I'm too old for this back and forth shyt lol

 

[calh45]

Nah.

If Reggie Wayne and Tory **** ain't in then he won't be either.

 

[FabTrey]

Difference is Mike Evans has a ring

Rings only matter for QBs, IMO. Randy Moss doesn’t have a ring, but he’s still my 2nd GOAT.


Fear factor matters to me cuz it changes the way defense plays. Who would teams fear more: Larry Fitzgerald or Mike Evans?


Evans will get in with his bulk stats, but i would not expect 1st ballot unless he does something truly special for next 2-3 years.

 

[feelosofer]

I forgot about Tiki. Another RB who was better than Frank.

Now you're being silly

If you hate Frank Gore just say that.

Frank has almost 5000 more yards and 30 more TD and half the fumbles.

 

[DallasTxRep]

Damn I didn't know he only caught 80+ passes twice and 90+ passes once in his career he's gonna get in the Hall tho, very good WR

 

[premier58]

Now you're being silly

If you hate Frank Gore just say that.

Frank has almost 5000 more yards and 30 more TD and half the fumbles.

Why would I hate Frank Gore? I grew up a Hurricanes fan. Total stats due to longevity. His peak isnt close to Tiki. Tiki also manged to play a decade.