Is Mike Evans A HOF Player?

KING WILL

Superstar
Joined
Jun 14, 2018
Messages
8,844
Reputation
1,382
Daps
22,882
**** vs Evans.

166 games vs 168
914 catches vs 836
13.7k yards vs 12.6k
15.0 ypc vs 15.2
66 tds vs 105 tds


**** kills him in receptions. Evans kills him in tds.

Traded out Terrys numbers for Julio Jones numbers.

WTF!!!!!! LOL. And JJ played 13 years. 2 extra years. 2 less games. 39 less TD's.


Guys bigging up mythical peaks, while turning a blind eye to TD's...
 

VegetasHairline

Veteran
Joined
Jun 25, 2012
Messages
39,762
Reputation
16,723
Daps
165,227
Reppin
CACS
Traded out Terrys numbers for Julio Jones numbers.

WTF!!!!!! LOL. And JJ played 13 years. 2 extra years. 2 less games. 39 less TD's.


Guys bigging up mythical peaks, while turning a blind eye to TD's...
This is why I always preferred Dez Bryant to Julio Jones.
:manny:
 

FabTrey

Superstar
Joined
Apr 2, 2017
Messages
13,225
Reputation
-1,648
Daps
28,891
Damn.

Mikes overlooked TD numbers become more and more impressive with each comparison.


He’s consistent, but the Hall is for legends, not just for racking up stats. His stats will get him in for sure. probably 2nd or 3rd ballot. Personally, I just don't think he was a 'great' player. He was a very very very good player. Great WRs to me are a rare breed. They aren't many that changes the game.

I feel like HOF in the NFL should be all about the best player in the game. I'm ok tory ho lt, hines ward, etc not getting in. was Evans at any point of his career considered top 2-3? I doubt it. even in 2018 he was behind, julio, dhop, reek, and michael thomas. I feel like he was always top 5-9 type.
 
Last edited:

JealousOnesEn_V

HTX Certified
Joined
May 19, 2012
Messages
2,649
Reputation
431
Daps
8,309
He’s consistent, but the Hall is for legends, not just for racking up stats. His stats will get him in for sure. probably 2nd or 3rd ballot. Personally, I just don't think he was a 'great' player. He was a very very very good player. Great WRs to me are a rare breed. They aren't many that changes the game.

I feel like HOF in the NFL should be all about the best player in the game. I'm ok tory ho lt, hines ward, etc not getting in. was Evans at any point of his career considered top 2-3? I doubt it. even in 2018 he was behind, julio, dhop, reek, and michael thomas. I feel like he was always top 5-9 type.

Do you think Larry Fitzgerald, Reggie Wayne, Steve Smith or Anquan Bolden should be in the HOF?
 

BucciMane

Kristina Schulman Bro
Supporter
Joined
Mar 4, 2015
Messages
33,707
Reputation
-2,654
Daps
75,440
Reppin
The Real Titletown
Do you think Larry Fitzgerald, Reggie Wayne, Steve Smith or Anquan Bolden should be in the HOF?

I think the names you just stated are actually very good comparisons, especially Fitzgerald.

When looking statistically, Fitzgerald and Evans had similar careers, with Evans having a better ypc. Fitzgerald is in, and I think he had an "aura" about him when he was playing and was one of those players that everyone loved. Not saying people don't like Evans, but it was different with Fitzgerald and I believed that helped him as well. He also had more 1,400 yard seasons than Evans if we're talking top end performance.

For Wayne, Smith Sr., and Boldin, I would say no.:manny:.
 

FabTrey

Superstar
Joined
Apr 2, 2017
Messages
13,225
Reputation
-1,648
Daps
28,891
Do you think Larry Fitzgerald, Reggie Wayne, Steve Smith or Anquan Bolden should be in the HOF?

Larry Fitzgerald is the only 1st ballot among those 4 IMO. other 3 needs to wait.

I think the names you just stated are actually very good comparisons, especially Fitzgerald.

When looking statistically, Fitzgerald and Evans had similar careers, with Evans having a better ypc. Fitzgerald is in, and I think he had an "aura" about him when he was playing and was one of those players that everyone loved. Not saying people don't like Evans, but it was different with Fitzgerald and I believed that helped him as well. He also had more 1,400 yard seasons than Evans if we're talking top end performance.

For Wayne, Smith Sr., and Boldin, I would say no.:manny:.


Fitzgerald is a tier above if you ask me.
 

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
45,404
Reputation
2,740
Daps
65,972
Reppin
The Yay
Some folks really have irrational dislike of players with longevity. Mike Evans is getting into HoF. Probably not first ballot but he's getting in.

Many really underrate the ability of players in the NFL producing consistently like a machine year in year out.


Same goes for Frank Gore.
 
Top