Is Mike Evans A HOF Player?

MikelArteta

Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
252,063
Reputation
31,634
Daps
770,286
Reppin
Top 4
Breh that isn't a HOF career. Reggie Wayne and Torry **** still aren't in it despite having much better careers.

If the consensus is Matt Ryan doesn't deserve to be in Canton then how can you justify this cat being in it?

11 straight 1,000 yard seasons

almost 13,000 yards
over 100 receiving tds (currently 9th all time)
 

MikelArteta

Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
252,063
Reputation
31,634
Daps
770,286
Reppin
Top 4
I'm sure I've said it befor ein this thread, but he's a lock for the HOF.

Only question now is if he's first-ballot or not. He's got a ring, has a strong argument as the GOAT of a NFL franchise, he has numbers regardless of level of QB play and is on pace to do something at the WR position that not even Jerry Rice could do.

he's still productive, even if he plays only two more years and gets 2,000 yards
that would bring him to top 10 all time in receiving yards and he's already top 10 right now in receiving tds
 

Ohene

Free Sheist
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
73,813
Reputation
6,368
Daps
127,187
Reppin
Toronto
Breh that isn't a HOF career. Reggie Wayne and Torry **** still aren't in it despite having much better careers.

If the consensus is Matt Ryan doesn't deserve to be in Canton then how can you justify this cat being in it?
he will make the hall of fame. lol, it isnt even an argument

he has a 100 touchdowns and > 10 straight 1000 yard seasons. He played his whole career on one team and has a super bowl. He is also associated with Tom Brady. He is getting in. Shoulda been all pro in 2018 too

and matt ryan is nobody compared to mike evans
matt ryan aint shyt
 

GilSho

Veteran
Joined
May 22, 2014
Messages
14,671
Reputation
2,146
Daps
93,600
he will make the hall of fame. lol, it isnt even an argument

he has a 100 touchdowns and > 10 straight 1000 yard seasons. He played his whole career on one team and has a super bowl. He is also associated with Tom Brady. He is getting in. Shoulda been all pro in 2018 too

and matt ryan is nobody compared to mike evans
matt ryan aint shyt
A player that was never Top 5 in his career making the HOF because people are obsessed with round numbers absolutely insane to me.

Matt Ryan actually won MVP and you're claiming he isn't shyt compared to this dude who's never been All-Pro even once. :dead:
 

Ohene

Free Sheist
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
73,813
Reputation
6,368
Daps
127,187
Reppin
Toronto
A player that was never Top 5 in his career making the HOF because people are obsessed with round numbers absolutely insane to me.

Matt Ryan actually won MVP and you're claiming he isn't shyt compared to this dude who's never been All-Pro even once. :dead:
MVP is a glorified best QB award. Matt Ryan aint shyt and had the worst choke job in a superbowl
like i said mike evans has been all pro twice but who cares. you probably dont think Eli Manning is a hall of famer for the same reason but guess what, he will be

on any given time there can be 2-5 receivers on the field compared to 1 QB. It is much harder to make all-pro for WR than it is for QBs as a result. Do your googles...everyone knows Mike Evans will be a HOF. I dont make the rules but he will be.
 

Reggie

Veteran
Joined
May 19, 2012
Messages
91,289
Reputation
4,842
Daps
192,703
Reppin
Virginia
In some rare cases it's not about the All Pro or Pro Bowl nods. But to not acknowledge a cat who does his job for over a decade straight with mediocrity the majority of his career would be foolish. He's still putting up numbers and once/if he finishes top 5-10 in all the major receiving categories all this will be a moot point.
 

MegaTronBomb!

Power is in my hair nikka
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
14,010
Reputation
2,331
Daps
43,164
Reppin
From The Westside With Love
:mjlol::mjlol: @ mfs saying he first ballot when the second best wr stat wise wasn’t a first ballot hall of famer

Mike Evans hasn't been a polarizing person like TO was.

The fact that biases due to personality/likability is even a determining factor is why votes should be public....cause then these voters would then have to make valid arguments for why they didn't vote for people....and ultimately it'd be reason for them to lose voting right for being on BS.

 

Bigwhite2498

All Star
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
8,580
Reputation
220
Daps
8,459
Mike Evans hasn't been a polarizing person like TO was.

The fact that biases due to personality/likability is even a determining factor is why votes should be public....cause then these voters would then have to make valid arguments for why they didn't vote for people....and ultimately it'd be reason for them to lose voting right for being on BS.
Ik he hasn’t but I think he couldn’t be a hall of fame 1st ballot for that exact reason those mfs are petty. That kinda was I meant when I brought up T.O lol
 

MikelArteta

Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
252,063
Reputation
31,634
Daps
770,286
Reppin
Top 4
TorreyHolt, Reggie Wayne, Steve Smith didn't make it yet, but we talking about someone who might've never even been a top 10 Wide Receiver in any season he played.

:mjlol:

did torry ****, reggie wayne, steve smith have 100 receiving tds?

at age 31 steve smith had 8,500 yards and 52 tds
at age 31 reggie wayne had 9,353 and 63 tds
at age 31 torry **** had 11,927 yard and 71 tds
at age 31 mike evans has 12684 and 105 tds
 
Last edited:

Ohene

Free Sheist
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
73,813
Reputation
6,368
Daps
127,187
Reppin
Toronto
In some rare cases it's not about the All Pro or Pro Bowl nods. But to not acknowledge a cat who does his job for over a decade straight with mediocrity the majority of his career would be foolish. He's still putting up numbers and once/if he finishes top 5-10 in all the major receiving categories all this will be a moot point.
exactly. In that offense he probably ends up with:

14,000 yards
120 touchdowns
5-6 pro bowls
1 super bowl

thats a hell of a resume. the only knock is the lack of pro bowl nods
 

Tommy Sheppard

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
17,228
Reputation
1,863
Daps
51,091
Reppin
NULL
For everyone saying Mike Evans isn't a Hall of Fame player, do y'all think Hines Ward belongs in the Hall of Fame?
:jbhmm:
no and I’m a steeler fan, ab has more yards receiving that him with almost 100 less catches. Hines has him beat by only 2 touchdowns. And is like 30th in yards.

Hines will probably get in 20+ years from now off of some symphony.
 
Top