Is madden really as bad as people make it out to be?

bigrice25

DUUUVAAAAAALL!!!
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
723
Reputation
90
Daps
906
Reppin
DUUUVAAAAAAAAAL
IMO it's a year to year build up of frustration. I wont be buying the next one unless it gets some really good user reviews.

for the Poster above, Franchise was damn near unplayable most of the year due to Franchise ending glitches. And how stale the Franchise mode is now with how little they have upgraded it... They've actually taken more features out of Franchise mode over the years.. No innovation...

It's bad.
 

Womb Raider

movin' thru the city streets
Joined
Aug 23, 2014
Messages
27,358
Reputation
7,406
Daps
93,137
Reppin
Fo Nem
I only play it after it comes to EA play, my days of wasting money on Madden are over
 

7th Letter Specialist

I don't swear to God, I just swear to Me.
Joined
Nov 21, 2017
Messages
10,662
Reputation
4,551
Daps
40,082
Reppin
Oakland, CA
I think this, w/ a lot of sports games have fallen off a bit because:

-Theyre just pachenko machines in longform

-the unpredictability of sports and balancing is an issue ("2k be cheating, I ain't never seen brah do that!")

-And it's more a diceroll of attributes and animations rather than actual skill. Just look at football and hoop games from like the early to mid aughts till now. The collision and animation was a tad sloppy looking but it was more accurate. Now every collision, bump, hit has a canned animation to it.

-also the fact that we kinda bytch and moan about every little blade of grass, if such and such wears a visor irl, does the ball have the Spalding logo on it etc. They can't skimp on the aesthetics cuz we're sticklers and can compare it almost daily
 

threattonature

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
22,813
Reputation
3,533
Daps
72,810
I think this, w/ a lot of sports games have fallen off a bit because:

-Theyre just pachenko machines in longform

-the unpredictability of sports and balancing is an issue ("2k be cheating, I ain't never seen brah do that!")

-And it's more a diceroll of attributes and animations rather than actual skill. Just look at football and hoop games from like the early to mid aughts till now. The collision and animation was a tad sloppy looking but it was more accurate. Now every collision, bump, hit has a canned animation to it.

-also the fact that we kinda bytch and moan about every little blade of grass, if such and such wears a visor irl, does the ball have the Spalding logo on it etc. They can't skimp on the aesthetics cuz we're sticklers and can compare it almost daily
Ain't gone lie, I HATE with a passion them MFs that be doing that. EA will release a patch and you have people talking about legit mode breaking bugs and then a couple lames like "George Kittle wears a black mouthguard now but it's still white in the game. EA doesn't care about fans".
 

feelosofer

#ninergang
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
46,897
Reputation
6,416
Daps
129,777
Reppin
Brick City, NJ
Yes. This past Madden Franchise mode was basically unplayable with the glitches.

The canned animations hurt the gameplay there is no reason that player strength, weight, attributes etc should not have more realistic physics. It felt more 'real' on the PS2 era.

Its clear Madden has abandoned the single player experience for what amounts to a gatcha game because kids spend millions upon millions on those Madden ultimate team cards.

NBA2K has flaws but the base game is better and they still have an extremely solid single player experience.

But since Madden is the only football game in town they feel no need to improve. All you need is to boycott Madden 1 year.
 

MrSpook

All Star
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
1,841
Reputation
331
Daps
3,559
Every year I've bought it when it was on sale for like $20. I'll start out enjoying it and thinking how much I miss playing it. Then the flaws start creeping in. I'd end up taking all kinds of videos sending friends like "look at this bullshyt, how is this still broke".

My biggest beef with the game is that every year it seems some position was broken. I used to love building teams with different strengths. I remember one year I got a team with prime Aaron Donald and JJ Watts both on the D-Line. They'd go against a O-line where every player is a 75 or below overall yet were being single covered and couldn't get off their bocks at all. Other years a sick DB group that routinely blew coverages or getting styled on by subpar WRs even in man coverage with guys with high coverage ratings.

Then you add in the overpowered DBs, CPU defenders able to stop on a dime at full speed and change direction without slowing down, high rated OL just going dumb at random and I eventually just give it up because it stops being fun and more frustrating. This is the first year I didn't even buy on sale.
You not missing shyt.

I don’t know why people in here talking about franchise because all those positions problems you were talking about shine the most there.

Stacked d line, receiver core, oline means shyt on madden against cpu, the mechanics are still weird asf. You still lean on olinemen without trying to when you runn the ball, wrs catching passes over two dbs routinely(not even wrs who’ve done it in real life).


For some time zeke still had a X factor, Josh jacobs literally just got his recently… game is ass I don’t care what nobody says.

Your QB can’t even catch wind from another player or they make him overthrow everything. You can throw to the right out of fear but sense someone was deadass just a couple yards by they’ll make your ball end up on the left field in a dbs hand somehow.

Tackling is shyt still…

Dline gets off blocks fast ASF.

If there was other options folks wouldn’t buy the shyt.
 

The Devil's Advocate

Call me Dad
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
35,439
Reputation
7,644
Daps
98,315
Reppin
Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven
Gameplay wise it isn’t imo if u play franchise, franchise can be very immersive, there will be times it gets a lil cheesy on both ends both for the most part franchise is a decent gaming experience


Definitely isn’t as good as 08 or sumn but it’s decent

H2H gameplay is where shyt gets awful, game endorses BS, superstar abilities can break the game, DBs are superhuman etc

I wouldn’t buy it, I bought madden every year up until 22. Now I just play modded games
Franchise been the same thing for 10 years now.. There is no immersion in that shyt..

Gameplay is the only thing that gets updated.. You play a madden from 2-3 years ago and you'll get through franchise with no help... But you wouldn't even be able to pass the same way in madden 21
 

HipHopStan

Top 113 Poster
Joined
Mar 29, 2013
Messages
16,880
Reputation
4,554
Daps
62,893
Reppin
I LIVE IN A CARDBOARD BOX!
Watching the players get mowed down by an ambulance in the older games was always fun.

giphy.gif


That vehicle still hits better than the entire Detroit Lions defense. :mjgrin:
 

rabbid

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
6,122
Reputation
1,275
Daps
21,286
I wouldn't know either as i havent played it since like '12 or '13. But back then there was at least NCAA to bounce ideas off of. Now there's nothing and i doubt its gotten dramatically better since then. It just looked at the reviews for the latest one and it seems garbage.
 

Legal

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
15,972
Reputation
3,172
Daps
60,885
Reppin
NULL
its not imo. i say that as a solo franchise only person that completes many years in that mode
most of the glitches in videos people show. i've never seen them playing madden.

Same. I don't see any of the crazy glitches that get posted. The game isn't anywhere near where it should be as far quality, but it definitely isn't the flaming pile of trash some of these folks on Twitter or YouTube make it out to be.

A lot of the issues source from the fact that the game is balanced around online/competitive play, so shyt like the D Line being way too overpowered happens in response to those players always looking for new busted plays, or ways to exploit non player controlled players, and establishing a new meta. As soon as I saw that folks were winning high level tournaments without even bothering to throw the ball, shyt was going to get crazy. Not trying to get a game out every year before the preseason is over would probably help them overhaul everything, but we all know that ain't happening.

Ain't gone lie, I HATE with a passion them MFs that be doing that. EA will release a patch and you have people talking about legit mode breaking bugs and then a couple lames like "George Kittle wears a black mouthguard now but it's still white in the game. EA doesn't care about fans".

Yeah, that always comes across as annoying. I saw a Reddit thread where people were complaining that the image in the reflection of the Lombardi trophy was actually of an empty stadium, and pulling the usual "EA IS LAZY!!!" card. We getting that granular to find shyt to get mad about? :mjlol:
 

Po pimp

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
12,823
Reputation
2,094
Daps
47,685
Reppin
Chi-Town
I haven’t played it much offline, so I don’t know if certain things can be tweaked with sliders. As far as playing against people online, there are WAY too many interceptions. Also it seems too difficult dissuading people from playing dumb, like going for it on say…4th and 4 back at their own 20 yard line, because 9 times out of ten, they’ll convert. I’m not even saying this because I suck. I’m like 40 games above .500 online.

Another thing that’s wrong with the game is the presentation is stale compared to say NBA 2k. Commentary isn’t terrible, but theres no variation with the visual presentation.
 

Po pimp

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
12,823
Reputation
2,094
Daps
47,685
Reppin
Chi-Town
Madden has some things I wish 2k would implement in their game, like the momentum and home field advantage. I like that on Madden, it goes up after a big play or a touchdown. On 2k, they have that takeover system with all these little icons on the screen at once that happen at the most random moments in the game. Not only that, how is it possible for BOTH teams to be in takeover mode at the same time? Makes zero sense.
 
Top