Is Logan the best superhero movie ever?

[MartyMcFly]

No.

Is it the most overrated superhero movie ever though? Getting there very fast I'd say.

Okay now that's going TOO far in the other direction. I'm sure I'll regret this but what's your beef with it

 

[KevCo]

Top 3 easily.


Need more time to marinate on it but it's far above anything that's released since dark knight.

Like you said, gotta let it marinate more, ive only seen it once...but right now dofp>>>
great flick tho, just ordered the blu ray, cant wait to see it again

 

[O.T.I.S.]

Possibly


It's at least top 3 and VERY underrated Imo

 

[Mowgli]

Nobody died. Zero stakes

Captain America. Doesn't roll like the 3 stooges like Logan's dumb ass. Pure effiency.

Disaster averted.

Logan failed everyone

 

[MartyMcFly]

Captain America. Doesn't roll like the 3 stooges like Logan's dumb ass. Pure effiency.

Disaster averted.

Logan failed everyone

He didn't fail everyone breh. But the people who did die reinforces the point about wolverine that's always been there in the comics. People who get close to him suffer or die

 

[Mowgli]

. People who get close to him suffer or die

Then I guess the little girl will be ok

He left her in the woods while being dead. He failed Xavier. He failed the X-Men. KahMaaaaahn

 

[MartyMcFly]

Then I guess the little girl will be ok

He left her in the woods while being dead. He failed Xavier. He failed the X-Men. KahMaaaaahn

He got her and friends to the border breh lol. That was his mission. And clearly they can handle themselves now that they've gotten rid of the one entity hunting them down.

 

[HHR]

Possibly


It's at least top 3 and VERY underrated Imo

This thread is titled "IS LOGAN THE BEST SUPERHERO MOVIE EVER?" and you come in saying it's underrated.

 

[HHR]

But, no. It's not.

It does an excellent job of pushing, or rather blending, superhero tropes with those of other genres, but the plotting wasn't particularly interesting and at times kind of insulting.

 

[O.T.I.S.]

This thread is titled "IS LOGAN THE BEST SUPERHERO MOVIE EVER?" and you come in saying it's underrated.

Yes...

It is probably the greatest comic book movie ever made but it did not FEEL like a comic book movie. Thats why I think most people will underrate it as a comic book film. It was very dark and emotional... comic book nerds don't like that

You just said it yourself that it's not, YOU don't even consider it... so because of people like you is why I think it's underrated

 

[Truetalk]

Nobody mentioned cap america civil war as a top movie

 

[Ironman]

He got her and friends to the border breh lol. That was his mission. And clearly they can handle themselves now that they've gotten rid of the one entity hunting them down.

There's a reason I avoid these threads brotha

 

[Ironman]

Nobody mentioned cap america civil war as a top movie

WS>CW to me personally

 

[Mowgli]

The Dr. Manhattan origin is some of the best stuff ever filmed in any comic book film. Along with the intro.

Anybody that calls Snyder a hack is clueless.

Watchmen>Logan

 

[Neuromancer]

top 5 easily.

Batman Begins
Winter Soldier
Dark Knight
The Watchmen
Logan.