Is Derrick Henry the best RB you ever seen?

[South Paw]

nikkas in here droppin' names like Shaun A, The Bus and B. Jacobs

Shaun prime was very dominant but he was soft as hell

Henry def better

 

[South Paw]

Shaun Alexander was a product of his oline and probably one of the most overrated rbs that were productive. Doesn't mean he didn't deserve the mvp, but talent wise he isn't up there with others. Once that oline fell apart, he was pedestrian as hell. Right there with Priest Holmes as one of the biggest running products of their olines. But at least Priest was a beast catching the ball.


I thought of his name when that is Matt Ryan the worst player to have won mvp thread came up.

Shaun had elite vision some of the best I've seen for a rb

 

[yseJ]

Shaun prime was very dominant but he was soft as hell

Henry def better

When Steve Hutchinson left ya'll Shaun turned to fools gold

 

[Trav]

Shaun prime was very dominant but he was soft as hell

Henry def better

Madden 07' was my shyt

And don't get me wrong. I'm not trying to play him or any one of the ones I mentioned like they're trash or anything. I just wouldn't take them over a prime Henry. Especially if he strings together another year(s) like the past few.

 

[Crude]

Shaun Alexander was a product of his oline and probably one of the most overrated rbs that were productive. Doesn't mean he didn't deserve the mvp, but talent wise he isn't up there with others. Once that oline fell apart, he was pedestrian as hell. Right there with Priest Holmes as one of the biggest running products of their olines. But at least Priest was a beast catching the ball.


I thought of his name when that is Matt Ryan the worst player to have won mvp thread came up.

That's a fair analysis. He made the most of his opportunity.

 

[mastermind]

You acting like Alexander wasn't an MVP and offensive player of the year and didn't rush for a over 1,500 yards multiple seasons.

Henry might be better, but it isn't a far fetched comparison either.

You acting like I said LenDale White > Derrick Henry or some far fetched BS like that.

I didn't shyt on Shaun Alexander. I know what his resume is, but like @yseJ said, dude was a product of that line. I don't think Shaun Alexander was garbage, but that was a very talented team in Seattle, with the best or second-best line in the NFL. Derrick Henry is doing something very different with the Titans. THat line is rated as a middle of the pack this year and Henry is leading the NFL in rushing. Its not the same.

Derrick Henry looks like a HOFer.

 

[South Paw]

When Steve Hutchinson left ya'll Shaun turned to fools gold

Shaun got hurt that year too and it was never the same

Emmit def way better than Shaun but hes also a rb that benfited from being behind an elite oline if we been 100

 

[OG Talk]

College-Reggie Bush

NFL- Walter Payton

 

[Leavingtheecstasy]

The Titans are Literally screaming "were giving the ball to derrick henry"

And he still scores and dominates


He can be a top 5 back all time on this trajectory

 

[Deus]

Trent Richardson must be in his feelings going thru this thread.

 

[South Paw]

I'm patiently awaiting the Travis Kelce thread

 

[mastermind]

That's what I came in to say about Marshall. I guess people forget his Colt years.

He was great during his Colt years, but those were trash teams. Faulk made three all-pro teams in Indy.

 

[BucciMane]

Nah, he better than Shawn Alexander. You doing too much.

nikkas in here droppin' names like Shaun A, The Bus and B. Jacobs

I'm glad you guys noticed that immediately as well. I damn near fell out of my chair reading that..

 

[28 Gramz]

No

AP
Barry
Emmitt
Eddie George
Faulk

 

[mastermind]

No

AP
Barry
Emmitt
Eddie George
Faulk

One of these things is not like the other ones...