Stop. Indy's defenses in the Manning years were always weak. You got some nerve talking about revisionist history, lol.
I don't know why you're mentioning Tampa. They were the GOAT cover 2 but they had beastly personnel and could stifle teams for 48 minutes, not just get sacks when they're up by 20.
The defense played well in 06 when they won, largely due to Bob Sanders returning for the playoffs and balling out. But let's not forget who they played that year.
The Ravens with no offense. McNair was
at that point.
The Bears with Rex Grossman. Nuff said.
Who couldn't stop those 2 anemic offenses?
And the Pats when they had the worst WR Brady ever had in his career. Reche Caldwell, Jabar Gaffney and them. And they still dropped 34.
Every other year, their D got smashed on in the playoffs.