In 2018 can we finally admit that Toby Mcguire was the GOAT spiderman?

[Luke Cage]

Andrew Garfield is the best Spider-man. Tobey was a creepy weirdo who just stared at people awkwardly all the time. Peter Parker was never like that. Tom Holland is better, but he comes across as too twitchy and over excited and that annoys me a little bit. Garfield's spider-man felt like a loner while still seeming cool and witty

Peter parker isnt supposed to be cool. Hes a dork.

 

[MartyMcFly]

Peter parker isnt supposed to be cool. Hes a dork.

Counter to that. Peter starts as a dork and grows into being a cool guy. He always sticks out and has his weirdness because thats who he is, but once be gets his group of friends (Flash, Harry, MJ, Gwen, etc) and gets a motorcycle and starts living with Harry during college, he grows out of that awkward dork phase and becomes a normal guy. well as normal as Peter could be anyway. I mean shyt, the guy ends up becoming Tony's protege, gets his doctorate, and starts his own business.

 

[Notorious 1 E.Y.E.]

toby wasnt even athletic , niggga moved like that 70's cartoon spiderman

 

[CHICAGO]

Lol. fukk nah. Holland )))) both. That being said Far from home was ass.

LMAO

FAR FROM HOME IS THE GOAT SPIDEY MOVIE



​

 

[Marc Spector]

Nope. Holland is.

 

[hostsamurai]

LMAO

FAR FROM HOME IS THE GOAT SPIDEY MOVIE



​

Wrong. Spiderman 2 is a top 10 all time superhero movie.

 

[Marc Spector]

Dont get me wrong: MCU Spidey is a extremely sanitized version of Spider Man.

The bullies arent as brutal.

Aunt May isnt a sickly old lady but a goddamn cougar and knows about Peter as Spider Man.

The Parkers don't seem to be poor or struggling.

He has Stark Enterprises and the Avengers as resources

And LOL at how uncle ben got thrown in the bushes so Stark can be the dead dad figure

Theres an argument that MCU Spidey doesnt embody the struggle like past iterations, but with that said Holland still is the best performer imo

 

[klientel]

Toby was only good when there was noone else to compare him too...

Tom Holland is wayyyyyyyyyy better.

 

[Gold]

Toby was only good when there was noone else to compare him too...

Tom Holland is wayyyyyyyyyy better.

Yall know nothing of Spiderman.

Tom holland blew up that asain ladies shop and slept like a baby that night.

Toby woulds been distraught or some shyt.

Tom Holland Spiderman only sad when we cant talk to mj or ironman. The emotional depth of his chacter is like a bottle of capri sun

 

[sfgiants]

Toby McGuire Spider-Man was a weird emo hipster fakkit and Mary Jane was ugly as fukk

 

[TEH]

I agree Toby the GOAT.

only people who disagree don’t know acting

 

[Jordan>>LeFrozen]

As someone else said

Toby was less like the comics and more of a real life adaption. By that I mean, if a college/high school dude who has been a loser most of his life really became Spider-Man, Toby is who he would be. The latest kid is more like the comics and Andrew was a split between someone trying to adjust to being a hero and someone trying to still live his confused life