interesting... dude lost me with the blue jeans part though
I watched Fight Club countless of times and never realized this!
- Thread starter gluvnast
- Start date
So those goons that took her off the bus weren't real? 
And Tyler Durden was a demon, breh. "Jack" picked him up during his support group meetings. There's nothing imaginary about being dragged and thrown down a flight of stairs. Fincher and Palahniuk did a great job being subtle about it. That's why at times he was possessed by Tyler and at times he saw him as a distinct being. The whole "we are the unwanted children of God, we don't need him
" speech is evidence as well.
And Tyler Durden was a demon, breh. "Jack" picked him up during his support group meetings. There's nothing imaginary about being dragged and thrown down a flight of stairs. Fincher and Palahniuk did a great job being subtle about it. That's why at times he was possessed by Tyler and at times he saw him as a distinct being. The whole "we are the unwanted children of God, we don't need him
" speech is evidence as well.
Bruce Wayne
THE GODDAMN BILLIONAIRE
Funny that this Thread pops up a week after I watched this Movie through for the 1st Time ever.
A Real Mind fukker but this is
A Real Mind fukker but this is
marla was real
I need to watch this movie again.
Marla was real. Tha fukk?
High quality poster
Veteran
Idk brehs.
But this movie is one big mindfukk anyway
GOAT movie tho!
But this movie is one big mindfukk anyway
GOAT movie tho!
Like I said, I watch it again to see for myself and Marla is definitely another figment of "Jack's" imagination. The REST, however, I don't buy. Such as, the house on Paper Street not being real (even though I DO believe it an abandoned house and nothing in there really works like the phone, or water, or electricity....I mean how can it?) Or Bob not being is suspect or a bit of a stretch, because there WAS indeed a scene where both Bob, "Jack", and Tyler were in the same basement (even though not all at the same time), and there's the death scene where all of his members started chanting Bob's name in honor of his death.... if Bob was imagined, then all the members must be imagined too (which very WELL could be) but I take it as a stretch.
Marla, on the other hand, IS NOT REAL. It, in fact, makes PERFECT SENSE as to the relevancy of her character and why Tyler always deemed her as a threat. This is why the film starts off with the introduction of Marla (well technically the introduction of Bob). Marla is the complete alternative to Tyler. The introduction of Marla was "Jack's" first alter-ego when he was constantly going to these different support groups to which he always came as a DIFFERENT person to begin with.... remember, he once called himself Cornelius in the group that Bob was in. Through those group was when Marla began to show and he IMMEDIATELY became disgusted by her because she's a reflection of HIMSELF. This was why Tyler was introduced afterwards. The moment of choice of which persona to embrace came when his condo blown up and he was to either call Marla or Tyler and he initially was about to call Marla but changed his mind and called Tyler.
Yet, throughout the movie, Marla kept trying to reenter into his subconsciousness. And "Jack" even stated how she sudden been "invading" his every move. "Jack" even stated he NEVER saw Tyler and Marla together, yet you ALWAYS saw Tyler as well as Marla interact with OTHER PEOPLE. The ONLY time you saw Tyler and Marla have a actual scene outright was she was overdosing and Tyler came to save her whereas "Jack" didn't want nothing to do with her, and that's the scene that was the most telling. From neither of them having mirror reflections to why "Jack" even transformed himself to Tyler to save Marla (which meant saving himself) to even Marla counting down to ten and Tyler miraculously made it from the abandoned house on Paper Street up to her hotel under 10 seconds flat to where she even stated in her drugged out state "damn, you're quick". They are all the same PERSON.
This movie's definitely "A Beautiful Mind" on steroids.
Marla, on the other hand, IS NOT REAL. It, in fact, makes PERFECT SENSE as to the relevancy of her character and why Tyler always deemed her as a threat. This is why the film starts off with the introduction of Marla (well technically the introduction of Bob). Marla is the complete alternative to Tyler. The introduction of Marla was "Jack's" first alter-ego when he was constantly going to these different support groups to which he always came as a DIFFERENT person to begin with.... remember, he once called himself Cornelius in the group that Bob was in. Through those group was when Marla began to show and he IMMEDIATELY became disgusted by her because she's a reflection of HIMSELF. This was why Tyler was introduced afterwards. The moment of choice of which persona to embrace came when his condo blown up and he was to either call Marla or Tyler and he initially was about to call Marla but changed his mind and called Tyler.
Yet, throughout the movie, Marla kept trying to reenter into his subconsciousness. And "Jack" even stated how she sudden been "invading" his every move. "Jack" even stated he NEVER saw Tyler and Marla together, yet you ALWAYS saw Tyler as well as Marla interact with OTHER PEOPLE. The ONLY time you saw Tyler and Marla have a actual scene outright was she was overdosing and Tyler came to save her whereas "Jack" didn't want nothing to do with her, and that's the scene that was the most telling. From neither of them having mirror reflections to why "Jack" even transformed himself to Tyler to save Marla (which meant saving himself) to even Marla counting down to ten and Tyler miraculously made it from the abandoned house on Paper Street up to her hotel under 10 seconds flat to where she even stated in her drugged out state "damn, you're quick". They are all the same PERSON.
This movie's definitely "A Beautiful Mind" on steroids.
Also, this definitely confirms that the initial motivation for all of this was due to "Jack" learning that he got testicular cancer and his struggles to cope with that. I didn't realize it before, but now it is as clear as day.
Majestyx
Duck Season
i guess the waiter was in on it too then
