How would you solve the immigration situation?

[#BOTHSIDES]

Have them fix up dilapidated neighborhoods, pick fruit, clean up trash, do the jobs Americans don’t want to do.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

Open up Ford , gm , and Boeing factories in El Salvador, Honduras, and Guatemala. Offer initial set up costs and tax incentives to companies that do so .

Your first step is to take away jobs from American citizens....... noted

 

[Formerly Black Trash]

Never going to rid of illegal immigration completely, but can get it way down.

1. Get rid of birthright citizenship. This has to be included in any real solution.
2. Illegals have absolutely no access to any american healthcare, education, etc. Make things very very hard for them. Don't mainstream them in anyway. Keep them in a bad place. You want word to get around that it's really not worth it. That working for a few dollars or being a whore is all that awaits them.
3. Be proactive in deporting them and crushing any business that uses them.
4. Absolutely no amnesty.


Now once you've got that system in place. Understand the usa has always had a need for cheap labor. So you implement a seasonal worker program. The program would offer certain benefits and protections. Folk will come legally, work their seasonal jobs, and leave because they understand they got nothing to gain from staying illegally.

I agree with everything except 4

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

Immigration is good for business..... so nothing will stop it

 

[ISO]

Step 1) Open up Ford , gm , and Boeing factories in El Salvador, Honduras, and Guatemala. Offer initial set up costs and tax incentives to companies that do so .

Step 2) Then immediately lift the silly sanctions on Venezuela.

Step 3) deport everyone from the above countries , but offer the deportees first dibs on the new jobs in their homelands. Then offer No more immigration trails in the US. Refer them to offices in their home countries if they have a legitimate refugee or asylum claim. (But I suspect they won't anymore)

Step 4) For bonus points , you can place one Intel factory on Haiti on the opposite side of port au prince and then immediately give Kenya 0.01% of the US defence budget to lay siege to the gangs in Port au prince.






These steps would quite literally double the gdp(s) of these nations and stop people from coming here. The idea is to fix the places these people are coming from so that there is no incentive to come to america.

And I doubt this would cost more than 5bil to do, which is nothing when compare to the US national budget. It'll cost far less than any immigration steps within the US .

What’s your plan for the West Africans?

 

[CopiousX]

What’s your plan for the West Africans?

They aren't the problem. They are less than 4% of the migrants. So they Honestly aren't a priority. africa is a Europe problem.our existing immigration and asylee/refugee system should be fine once these latin Americans stay at home.


Link-->

Profile of the Unauthorized Population - US

Learn about the estimated 11.4 million unauthorized immigrants living in the United States—where do they live? When did they arrive in the United States, and from which origin countries? What are their levels of education, top industries of employment, income, parental and marital status, health...

www.migrationpolicy.org

Honestly, India is bigger problem based on the stats

 

[Formerly Black Trash]

Step 1) Open up Ford , gm , and Boeing factories in El Salvador, Honduras, and Guatemala. Offer initial set up costs and tax incentives to companies that do so .

Step 2) Then immediately lift the silly sanctions on Venezuela.

Step 3) deport everyone from the above countries , but offer the deportees first dibs on the new jobs in their homelands. Then offer No more immigration trails in the US. Refer them to offices in their home countries if they have a legitimate refugee or asylum claim. (But I suspect they won't anymore)

Step 4) For bonus points , you can place one Intel factory on Haiti on the opposite side of port au prince and then immediately give Kenya 0.01% of the US defence budget to lay siege to the gangs in Port au prince.






These steps would quite literally double the gdp(s) of these nations and stop people from coming here. The idea is to fix the places these people are coming from so that there is no incentive to come to america.

And I doubt this would cost more than 5bil to do, which is nothing when compare to the US national budget. It'll cost far less than any immigration steps within the US .

Great plan

 

[Red Shield]

I agree with everything except 4

Why do you disagree...

From my view.. if you do amnesty, folk are just going to keep coming expecting amnesty to be granted again. And they would probably be right. So you can't do it.

 

[ISO]

They aren't the problem. They are less than 4% of the migrants. So they Honestly aren't a priority. africa is a Europe problem.our existing immigration and asyler/refugee system should be fine once these latin Americans stay at home.


Link-->

Profile of the Unauthorized Population - US

Learn about the estimated 11.4 million unauthorized immigrants living in the United States—where do they live? When did they arrive in the United States, and from which origin countries? What are their levels of education, top industries of employment, income, parental and marital status, health...

www.migrationpolicy.org

Honestly, India is bigger problem based on the stats

I’m in NYC a lot of the immigrants are West Africans.

 

[Formerly Black Trash]

Why do you disagree...

From my view.. if you do amnesty, folk are just going to keep coming expecting amnesty to be granted again. And they would probably be right. So you can't do it.

Because amnesty isn't granted to everyone who applies

And amnesty is a humanitarian issue

I don't think we should have no immigrants, I just think we need to not be overwhelmed

 

[Jesus H. Christ]

Deport them all. Fine companies who hire them severely. Deport their babies too

OP said a serious take not a MAGA fantasy.

 

[Red Shield]

Because amnesty isn't granted to everyone who applies

And amnesty is a humanitarian issue

I don't think we should have no immigrants, I just think we need to not be overwhelmed

Every country is gonna have some level of immigration, I'm just talking illegals.


But how is amnesty a humanitarian issue in this regard? These people aren't refugees, their economic migrants.

 

[fifth column]

Start turning unused land in middle America into accommodating neighborhoods just for immigrants who want a chance. Set up educational programs to help them catch up and job programs so that they can participate in the economy. Just doing the right humane things in life and stop looking for short cuts.

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

1. Get rid of birthright citizenship. This has to be included in any real solution.

Thats a constitutional amendment and will get complicated with the number of soldiers the USA has overseas

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

Start turning unused land in middle America into accommodating neighborhoods just for immigrants who want a chance. Set up educational programs to help them catch up and job programs so that they can participate in the economy. Just doing the right humane things in life and stop looking for short cuts.

Then we can wait 20 years to see how this turned out