Hip-Hop Blasphemy: It Was Written Is Better Than Illmatic (Episode 2)

Eddie Brock

All Star
Joined
Aug 24, 2015
Messages
2,207
Reputation
335
Daps
5,638
Not tryin to make any of my fellow brehs catch feelings, but in my experience it seems all the hardcore Nas fans (such as myself) always thought IWW is better than Illmatic :yeshrug:
 

Menelik II

I wanna see receipts!
Joined
Dec 4, 2016
Messages
4,914
Reputation
1,030
Daps
14,902
u gonna act like nikkaz were feeling this





over this





:snoop:

now should i've used the word c00nish ? NO
but saying thriller is better then OTW is completely outta pocket from an black person

that's like saying you prefer condiments like mayonnaise & yogurt over barbecue & hot sauce


nikkaz will be looking like ..... WHAT da fukk is wrong with you :scust:

I think you're oversimplifying this bruh. :yeshrug: MJs scale from OTW to Thriller isn't even comparable, he went from a v good artist to the biggest that we had even seen or even conceive. Plus thriller has all the milestones added like first black male on MTV, the moonwalk, first huge videos, Motown 25, etc etc. If you were to ask people around that time whether MJ could fly theyd be maybe :lupe: So ppl can't look at it clinically and objectively thriller vs off the wall, whether you are white or black or anything.

OWW was pretty much just the music, whereas thriller is all the other epic stuff. I love them both , like my main and side.

Either way, anyway, illmatic over IWW :coffee:
 

kingofnyc

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
26,732
Reputation
1,189
Daps
53,494
Reppin
Boogie Down BX
I think you're oversimplifying this bruh. :yeshrug: MJs scale from OTW to Thriller isn't even comparable, he went from a v good artist to the biggest that we had even seen or even conceive. Plus thriller has all the milestones added like first black male on MTV, the moonwalk, first huge videos, Motown 25, etc etc. If you were to ask people around that time whether MJ could fly theyd be maybe :lupe: So ppl can't look at it clinically and objectively thriller vs off the wall, whether you are white or black or anything.

OWW was pretty much just the music, whereas thriller is all the other epic stuff. I love them both , like my main and side.

Either way, anyway, illmatic over IWW :coffee:

breh

i'm not oversimplifying nothing nor comparing the two as of sales/popularity etc..
i simply made the distinction of the two

BTW - the song 'rock with u' from OTW (i believe) was the very 1st black video ever played on MTV
 

Menelik II

I wanna see receipts!
Joined
Dec 4, 2016
Messages
4,914
Reputation
1,030
Daps
14,902
breh

i'm not oversimplifying nothing nor comparing the two as of sales/popularity etc..
i simply made the distinction of the two


Saying black person preferring thriller over otw is "outta pocket" is oversimplying or being ignorant of how complex the question is. It's not just what was on the wax.

BTW - the song 'rock with u' from OTW (i believe) was the very 1st black video ever played on MTV

You got any receipts to go with this ? :laff::coffee:
 

spliz

SplizThaDon
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
60,516
Reputation
9,135
Daps
200,790
Reppin
NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
u gonna act like nikkaz were feeling this





over this





:snoop:

now should i've used the word c00nish ? NO
but saying thriller is better then OTW is completely outta pocket from an black person

that's like saying you prefer condiments like mayonnaise & yogurt over barbecue & hot sauce


nikkaz will be looking like ..... WHAT da fukk is wrong with you :scust:

No. but nikkas prefer this.


And this


And this


And this


To sit there and say it's something wrong with a black person to prefer Thriller is ignorant and ridiculous. Like I said. I prefer Off The Wall. But I understand someone picking Thriller cause the album had BANGERS. Mix that with the legendary visual's and performances he had associated with that album. It's EASY to understand why someone would prefer it. This is a stupid fukkin argument.
 

kingofnyc

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
26,732
Reputation
1,189
Daps
53,494
Reppin
Boogie Down BX
Saying black person preferring thriller over otw is "outta pocket" is oversimplying or being ignorant of how complex the question is. It's not just what was on the wax.

u sounding like u on some :mjpls: shyt

again... i personally never heard - well until now on this site any black person prefer thriller



You got any receipts to go with this ? :laff::coffee:

nah

i watch CNN 90's series a year ago & the episode on TV/cable the part of MTV's very beginnings -the documentary briefly covered them not playing black music... in which someone told the story behind them to start - mike was the biggest star in the world and his new album was soon dropping his record label told MTV if they don't play his vid they would blackball all their artist from the network (the song rock with u was playing in the background as the story was being told)




edit
i googled and some site -say billi jean was the 1st :yeshrug:
 

Menelik II

I wanna see receipts!
Joined
Dec 4, 2016
Messages
4,914
Reputation
1,030
Daps
14,902
u sounding like u on some :mjpls: shyt

again... i personally never heard - well until now on this site any black person prefer thriller




You do realise that most people under 25 haven't even listened to off the wall beginning to end, black or white? Your argument would have more weight with :flabbynsick: not across the age groups. The 2 albums are not as racially split as you protest
 

LEEeveryday

The-Coli Music Critic
Supporter
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
8,082
Reputation
4,066
Daps
30,449
Reppin
#LyricsMatter
This one of those topics people just go with the grain...

Because "I Gave You Power" is one of my all time favorite songs....IWW will always get more burn, so that's why I always say it's better.
 

Menelik II

I wanna see receipts!
Joined
Dec 4, 2016
Messages
4,914
Reputation
1,030
Daps
14,902

LEEeveryday

The-Coli Music Critic
Supporter
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
8,082
Reputation
4,066
Daps
30,449
Reppin
#LyricsMatter
This one of those topics people just go with the grain...

Because "I Gave You Power" is one of my all time favorite songs....IWW will always get more burn, so that's why I always say it's better.


Actually, I change my mind...

Illmatic is a much better body of work...I'm bumping that shyt right now :banderas:
 
Top