Your hypothetical is pointless. You're essentially saying GTA started off one way and needs to stay that way. The GTA 5 single player, sans any DLC is bigger than anything they've given us before. It's bigger than GTA 4 including both of its DLCs. Gamers were not shortchanged by Rockstar with GTA5. Yours, and others, complaints come down to feeling they didn't give you enough. 7 years of steady, free content, isn't enough because you didn't get your single player DLC. That's ridiculous. They poured a ton of time and resources into this game. Dislike it all you want, but that's not selling out in the slightest.
Gamers bytch and moan when they get incomplete games only to be charged for DLC that could have been in the game day one. Rockstar keeps giving nikkas free shyt for 7 years and some gamers are still bytching
I already said, if GTA 6 turns into an online only game, I'll be first to shyt on Rockstar. I'm not about to preemptively shyt on them for something that hasn't happened yet.
Maybe it's the instant gratification nature of the world today, but I remember gamers waiting longer for certain properties, without the privilege of an active online component to a game to occupy them, and not hearing anywhere near this level of whining. Imagine being a Half-Life fan reading this shyt
It's been how long since the last Bioshock? Diablo 3 was how long ago? You can bring up DLC for those and other games, but the content Rockstar has put out these last seven years blows all DLC out of the water in terms of size. So no, I'm not going to begrudge a company for getting with the times, especially if they do it in a consumer friendly way, which they have.