Charlie Campbell, Walterfootball.com
5. Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Alabama
The Dolphins take their future franchise quarterback. If the medical reports come back with positive news on Tagovailoa, I could see Miami taking him over Justin Herbert. If it weren't for his dislocated hip and durability concerns, Tagovailoa would be a lock as a high first-round pick.
18. Jedrick Wills Jr., T, Alabama
The Dolphins grab Tua Tagovailoa's blind-side protector. Sources say Miami is high on Wills. The 6-foot-5, 320-pound Wills was the starting right tackle for Alabama over the past two seasons and was a steady performer for the Crimson Tide. He has the strength to open holes in the ground game with the quickness and athleticism to block on the edge. Wills looks like a quick starter at right tackle in the NFL.
26. D'Andre Swift, RB, Georgia
The Dolphins grab a feature back for their offense. Miami really struggled to run in 2019 and needs more talent in the backfield along with a better offensive line. Some team sources are high on Swift and feel he is a better prospect than Nick Chubb, Sony Michel or Josh Jacobs were.
Walter Cherepinsky, Walter Football (1/23)
5. Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Alabama
I mentioned on our NFL picks podcast video that I was going to steal this pick. I also like the theory that the Dolphins will take Tua Tagovailoa anyway because they've been targeting this whole time. The Dolphins can start Ryan Fitzpatrick for one more year as Tagovailoa heals from his devastating injury.
18. D'Andre Swift, RB, Georgia
The Dolphins need to add tons of talent around their new quarterback to give him a fighting chance. They have so many holes on offense that almost every position makes sense. D'Andre Swift might be the best offensive player on the board. D'Andre Swift lives up to his name concerning that attribute, but vision is his best strength.
26. Tristan Wirfs, T, Iowa
The Dolphins addressed their offense with their first two selections. Here's a third pick for the offense, as the blocking desperately needs to be upgraded. Tristan Wirfs, a 320-pound tackle, needs to improve his pass protection, but he's a massive run blocker with first-round potential.
Dan Kadar, SB Nation
5. Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Alabama
As the draft process drags on, we'll learn more about the truth of Tagovailoa's health status. That will prove whether or not he slides, gets picked fifth overall, or goes even higher in a trade-up scenario.
18. Curtis Weaver, DE, Boise State
Miami has been in the bottom six of the NFL in sacks the last three seasons, and bottomed out as the worst in the league in 2019. That could force a move on a player like
Weaver in the first round. He reminds me of
Clelin Ferrell, whom the Raiders took fourth overall last year.
26. Mekhi Becton, T, Louisville
Becton bolted for the NFL after starting three seasons at Louisville, and should have a spot in the first round locked down. Now it's just a matter of figuring out how high he could go. The Dolphins would be wise to pair Tagovailoa with a blocker on the edge, and Becton fits the bill.
Michael Middlehurst-Schwartz, USA Today
5. Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Alabama
Maybe
hip surgery won't leave Tagovailoa out of action until the draft after all. His agent, Leigh Steinberg, said this week he expects the quarterback to be healthy by April and participate in a throwing session for teams. The former point is more important than the latter, as medical questions should be the only reason the Dolphins should have pause on an otherwise alluring passer.
18. Yetur Gross-Matos, DE, Penn State
Taco Charlton led Miami with a meager five sacks, and his standing with the team is unclear after he was made inactive for three of the final four games. Gross-Matos checks off a lot of boxes as a speed rusher off the edge,
26. Josh Jones, OT, Houston
Between Miami's 58 sacks allowed and rate of 3.3 yards per carry, it's clear an investment needs to be made up front, especially if an ascending talent like Jones is available in the first round.
Luke Easterling, Draft Wire
5. Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Alabama
They might have to move up to land him on draft day, but if Tagovailoa is still on the board here, it's a no-brainer for the Dolphins. Assuming his medicals check out, Tagovailoa is an elite quarterback prospect with all the physical and mental tools to be the difference-maker Miami has been desperately seeking for years.
18. Henry Ruggs III, WR, Alabama
After using their first pick on a franchise quarterback, the Dolphins need to build a worthy supporting cast around Tagovailoa. Why not start by giving him one of his favorite weapons from the college ranks? Tua has been taking advantage of Ruggs' elite explosiveness and big-play ability for quite some time now, and he could do the same in Miami for years to come.
26. Jonathan Taylor, RB, Wisconsin
Offensive tackle would be the top priority here, but with Mekhi Becton off the board just before their pick, the value is likely to be better at their next pick. Instead, the Dolphins could opt to take the best of a deep running back class, adding a complete runner in Taylor, who averaged 2,000 yards per season on the ground over his three years with the Badgers.
Vinnie Iyer, The Sporting News
5. Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Alabama
Now that we know Tagovailoa (6-1, 218 pounds) should make a full recovery from his scary hip injury, he has to be the pick for the Dolphins. Miami can keep Ryan Fitzpatrick to serve as the bridge QB should Tagovailoa need extra time to get to full strength. When healthy, Tagovailoa is an accurate, mobile, deep-ball throwing QB with the upside of Russell Wilson, only throwing with his left arm.
18. Jonathan Taylor, RB, Wisconsin
The Dolphins desperately need a true workhorse back for their rebuild. Taylor (5-11, 219 pounds) has great vision and burst as a runner. He also doesn't get enough credit for what he can do as a receiver, which was on display more during his final college season. In three years for the Badgers, he posted 6,581 scrimmage yards and 55 total TDs.
26. Justin Jefferson, WR, LSU
The Dolphins know DeVante Parker will be around for a while. Now they can get someone to complement him as a big-play threat outside. Jefferson (6-2, 185 pounds) has emerged in LSU's passing game as a quick, efficient route-runner with good hands whose speed remains underrated. He has posted 102 catches for 1,434 yards and 18 TDs in 14 games with one more left to play.
Brad Weiss, FanSided.com
3. Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Alabama
The Miami Dolphins have to get their quarterback in 2020, and with all the noise surrounding Tua Tagovailoa, the fact is, all signs point to him being able to fully heal from his hip injury. If that is the case, he is once again the best quarterback prospect in the draft, although he does fall to No. 3 here to Miami. Miami will have to trade up to get Tua, who was one of the more electric players in college football when healthy, but they will be glad they did once he is able to play. Last year, the Dolphins actually played competitive football despite the fact the organization kept selling off head coach Brian Flores' top guys, who that just shows you how good a coach they have in Flores.
18. Javon Kinlaw, DL, South Carolina
The Miami Dolphins hold three first round picks in the 2020 NFL Draft, but after moving up to draft Tua Tagovailoa, they end up with only two in this mock. The move up for Tua is a good one, as he is going to be a special talent in this league, and with their second first rounder, look for Brian Flores to attack the defensive side of the ball Of all the defensive tackles in this draft class, very few have the versatility of a guy like Javon Kinlaw from South Carolina. Of course, now that the draft process has started, there is a good chance that Kinlaw is gone before the Dolphins pick at No. 18, but he would be an excellent addition to this defensive line if not.
Kevin Hanson, Sports Illustrated
5. Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Alabama
Armed with three first-round picks and six in the top 70, the Dolphins are stocked with ammunition to move up if they feel it's necessary to land Tagovailoa. Clearly, there are durability concerns—not only because of the
hip injury that ended his collegiate career (even though
early reports have been positive), but he's had ankle surgeries in each of the past two seasons as well. When healthy, however, Tua has elite anticipation, accuracy and touch on all levels of the field, and he's
expected to throw for teams prior to the draft.
18. Mekhi Becton, T, Louisville
Not only did the Dolphins trade away left tackle Laremy Tunsil during the season, the team could use multiple upgrades in their offensive line, which finished last in
Football Outsiders offensive line rankings in 2019. Becton has incredible agility and movement skills for a man his size (6-7, 369 pounds), which led his former coach Bobby Petrino to once
compare Becton to Jonathan Ogden.
26. D'Andre Swift, RB, Georgia
Miami has holes all across its roster and can go in a number of directions here, but it had the league's worst rushing attack—72.3 yards per game and 3.3 yards per carry. Upgrading the offensive line is necessary as well (see No. 18), but Swift is an elusive runner with great burst and an accomplished receiver (73 receptions) to give the Dolphins a three-down back to take pressure off Tua.
Kristopher Knox, Bleacher Report
5. Justin Herbert, QB, Oregon
18. D'Andre Swift, RB, Georgia
26. Kristian Fulton, CB, LSU
Joe Tansey, Bleacher Report
5. Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Alabama
18. Tee Higgins, WR, Clemson
26. Bryce Hall, CB, Virginia
Michael Renner, Pro Football Focus
5. Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Alabama
Tua will have an asterisk next to his name all offseason, but with his injury timeline, we should know by draft day whether further complications have arisen that could put his career in jeopardy. Assuming full health, Tagovailoa did nothing to dissuade us from our preseason opinion that he's a franchise quarterback prospect with a 90.3 passing grade.
18. Josh Jones, T, Houston
Jones earned the highest overall grade we've ever given to a non-Power 5 offensive tackle (93.2). And unlike many Group-of-5 tackles, Jones has all the length and athleticism to stick there in the NFL.
26. C.J. Henderson, CB, Florida
Henderson won't be everyone's cup of tea, but he should taste just right for man-heavy defenses like the Dolphins'. Even with a relative down year this season, Henderson allowed only 20 catches all season long. He lost more downfield than he did in 2018, but he was often still at the catch point.
Scott Wright, Draft Countdown.com
5. Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Alabama
Miami's desire to land a franchise signal caller is the worst-kept secret in the league so this may merely be a question of Tagovailoa or Oregon's Justin Herbert. Tagovailoa's stock is clouded by a season-ending hip injury, which is just the latest in a string of lower body ailments. Indications are that Tagovailoa is expected to make a full recovery and if that's the case he should still be a Top 5 pick. If the medicals don't check out or the Dolphins are just generally concerned about his durability they could audible to Herbert, who the organization is also said to be high on. When healthy Tagovailoa is a dynamic playmaker in the mold of a Steve Young or Russell Wilson, capable of making plays with his arm and legs. Tagovailoa also possesses the top-notch intangibles needed to thrive as a quarterback in the NFL.
18. K'Lavon Chaisson, Edge, LSU
Assuming Miami gets a quarterback with their top pick, they will have considerable flexibility the rest of the way because they basically need help everywhere. That's one of the benefits of a complete rebuild. It only makes sense to surround that new signal caller with weapons and blockers. However, Phins head coach Brian Flores has a defensive background and will likely want to use at least one of those three first-rounders on a playmaker for that side of the ball. Upgrading the pass rush will be a priority after finishing dead-last in the league in sack production. Durability is a concern with Chaisson but when healthy he's proven to be a dynamic presence off the edge due to an ideal blend of explosive athleticism, speed and power. Chaisson isn't just a one-trick pony either, utilizing an array of moves and counters to get after the quarterback.
26. J.K. Dobbins, RB, Ohio State
Among the Dolphins myriad of problems is a severe lack of playmakers on offense. Especially in a run game that was dead last in the NFL. In this scenario they have their pick of the litter at the running back position, with Dobbins and D'Andre Swift of Georgia contending to be the first runner off the board. The Raiders rushing attack improved by leaps and bounds this year after selecting Josh Jacobs in the first round and Dobbins could have a similar type of impact in Miami. Dobbins is the total package at the position, excelling in all facets of the game. Whether it's as an instinctive ball carrier with a nice blend of speed and power, catching the ball out of the backfield or picking up the blitz as a blocker. Dobbins has also shown the ability to be a workhorse, carrying the load for the Buckeyes and rising to the occasion in big games.