Freddie Gibbs & Madlib - Cocaine Piñata - MARCH 18 (Official Discussion Thread)

[WEKetchum]

Pitchfork gave it a solid review (very well written actually).

http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/18930-freddie-gibbs-and-madlib-pinata/

I feel like the writeup doesn't match up with the score but thats because Pitchfork is real business minded these days... anything 8.0 + has to sit well with their customer base.

very well written.

*waits on people to call Pitchfork cacs and say they don't know about the culture*

 

[criminology]

very well written.

*waits on people to call Pitchfork cacs and say they don't know about the culture*

Well allow me to retort...

Nas-Untitled: 3.8
Mac Miller-Watching Movies With The Sound Off: 7.8

Mac Miller is 4 full points above Nas, over double the score. Mac Miller... double the score of a Nas album.

 

[WEKetchum]

Well allow me to retort...

Nas-Untitled: 3.8
Mac Miller-Watching Movies With The Sound Off: 7.8

Mac Miller is 4 full points above Nas, over double the score. Mac Miller... double the score of a Nas album.

Didn't hear the Mac Miller album, but from what I heard, it was really well done and went way above his expectations. Untitled was underappreciated all the way around by critics really, not just Pitchfork. I liked it, but figured I saw something in it that was apparently tough to figure out.

 

[Ohene]

Well allow me to retort...

Nas-Untitled: 3.8
Mac Miller-Watching Movies With The Sound Off: 7.8

Mac Miller is 4 full points above Nas, over double the score. Mac Miller... double the score of a Nas album.

lol as somebody that shunned Mac Miller, I can tell you with a straight face that Watching Movies is a better., more entertaining album than anything Nas put out since God's Son. Keep sleeping and stanning though. Godspeed.

 

[Only On Camera]

The sample during the hook of broken is too good

 

[King A.D 7]

lol as somebody that shunned Mac Miller, I can tell you with a straight face that Watching Movies is a better., more entertaining album than anything Nas put out since God's Son. Keep sleeping and stanning though. Godspeed.

 

[ZEB WALTON]

the albums production is soooo consistant. havent heard an album setup like this beat wise in a long time.

 

[Bob-omb]

Best Buy shipped out the album for me

 

[SubLyminalz]

I haven't skipped a song yet off the second listen :amazed:


the quotables on broken :amazed:

 

[The Jewnited States]

lol as somebody that shunned Mac Miller, I can tell you with a straight face that Watching Movies is a better., more entertaining album than anything Nas put out since God's Son. Keep sleeping and stanning though. Godspeed.

this song is literally worse than every song on this gibbs album by about 100000000 times. you see yourself playing that song in 5 years? hell even 1 year? if so, god help you.

 

[CDoty]

shyttsville

 

[Ohene]

this song is literally worse than every song on this gibbs album by about 100000000 times. you see yourself playing that song in 5 years? hell even 1 year? if so, god help you.

nikka whos talking about Gibbs...were talking about Nas. And I havent played any of his music since Stillmatic past a month period.

 

[CDoty]

I haven't skipped a song yet off the second listen :amazed:


the quotables on broken :amazed:

i'm 10 plays thru and i cant stop

 

[The Jewnited States]

this song wasn't even on it and it might be the best overall IMO

 

[The Jewnited States]

nikka whos talking about Gibbs...were talking about Nas. And I havent played any of his music since Stillmatic past a month period.

not even you believes that. i can name 20 nas tracks better than that in that time