Explain how to make Magneto work in the MCU without him being black or making it a period piece?

nieman

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
17,578
Reputation
2,415
Daps
34,774
Reppin
Philly
Some things don't need explaining. Hell, Capt Marvel has been in space for 20 years and not aged... they didn't even bother to explain it. However, the way I'd bring X-Men & F4 int the fold:

F4 - same space exploration/cosmic rays, only they were lost in space (X amount of years) some type of void, and the Snap gets them out of the void, back into the solar system to make their way home. But they already have their powers, possibly even Franklin and/or Valeria.

X-Men - keep their entire backstory in tact, and use part of the House of M/Five Lights storyline. And Magneto just physically ages slower. The X-Men are the proper adult ages, mutants have always existed, but since there were very few of them (lets say under 2000) in the world, aside from average random prejudice acts, they were on a smaller scale, so were monitored but not important. Some 10 or so years go, Jean Grey made the sacrifice and absorbed the Phoenix Force, carrying it into space, to save the world which very few knew about. The Snap breaks the Phoenix Force free from Jean, causing the Five Lights storyline...first mutant born, and new mutant powers activated around the world...causing global panic about the world's now unpredictable "Mutant problem." It's especially a problem when people realize that Mutants were born that way. Considered a disease, abomination, abnora, freaks....that brings you into the current climate of "I can't believe prejudice still exists like that today"" argument, that some of us still experience today.
 

CarltonJunior

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 21, 2014
Messages
47,715
Reputation
5,645
Daps
132,359
Reppin
Duval County
X-Men - keep their entire backstory in tact, and use part of the House of M/Five Lights storyline. And Magneto just physically ages slower. The X-Men are the proper adult ages, mutants have always existed, but since there were very few of them (lets say under 2000) in the world, aside from average random prejudice acts, they were on a smaller scale, so were monitored but not important. Some 10 or so years go, Jean Grey made the sacrifice and absorbed the Phoenix Force, carrying it into space, to save the world which very few knew about. The Snap breaks the Phoenix Force free from Jean, causing the Five Lights storyline...first mutant born, and new mutant powers activated around the world...causing global panic about the world's now unpredictable "Mutant problem." It's especially a problem when people realize that Mutants were born that way. Considered a disease, abomination, abnora, freaks....that brings you into the current climate of "I can't believe prejudice still exists like that today"" argument, that some of us still experience today.

Scarlett Witch and Quiksilver are already in the MCU and I think because of that it'll make it harder to convince people that people look down on mutants
 

Starman

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
15,912
Reputation
-2,886
Daps
35,013
Like 98 percent of the people during the Holocaust are dead now. How they gonna have a 100 yr old Jewish Magneto teaming up with Spiderman and Captain Marvel?


Making him black and a baby boomer/civil rights era baby makes more sense.


Magneto is fine the way he is. I understand you probably want more black representation, we all do, but chill. Magneto is Jewish and antisemitism still exists. If you need him to have a history of being oppressed, you still can.:yeshrug:
 

Cuban Pete

Aka 305DeadCounty
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
15,089
Reputation
8,159
Daps
70,842
Reppin
SOHH ICEY MONOPOLY
Black American/ADOS
Palestinian
Serbian

These are the only ones that would work and honestly Palestinian would be to controversial for Zionists so it should be ADOS raised in 1950s/60s South. If they wanna keep him white I have no issue with making him a survivor of the Balkans genocide
 

Scustin Bieburr

Baby baybee baybee UUUGH
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
21,573
Reputation
11,162
Daps
124,470
Nothing wrong with a period piece but they could just make his backstory one where he was in a country where there was a genocide and mutants were one of the people targeted
 

Fillerguy

Veteran
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
19,061
Reputation
4,525
Daps
79,817
Reppin
North Jersey
Since the MCU borrowed heavily from the Ultimate comics just do the came for Magneto. Just be a mutant supremacist and not have his origins stem from the holocaust.
C/s and You could still make him Jewish descendant of Holocaust survivors. Thats his motivation for why Humanity aint shyt:yeshrug:, aming other atrocities.

I really dont rock with the idea of a Black Magneto but it works on paper. We already got a hyper woke breh though, Killmonger.
 

richaveli83

Veteran
Joined
Sep 10, 2015
Messages
54,968
Reputation
20,756
Daps
270,999
Reppin
Dallas, Texas but living in Houston, Texas
Black American/ADOS
Palestinian
Serbian

These are the only ones that would work and honestly Palestinian would be to controversial for Zionists so it should be ADOS raised in 1950s/60s South. If they wanna keep him white I have no issue with making him a survivor of the Balkans genocide
They could also make him South African who grew up under apartheid during the 70s and 80s.
 
Last edited:

BXKingPin82

The Chairman of the Board will be... The Kingpin
Supporter
Joined
Jun 14, 2014
Messages
59,104
Reputation
13,522
Daps
199,367
Reppin
Bronx NY
Seriously tho, they need to really get that "Legend of the Blue Marvel" joint on the big screen.
51z9N9lQLrL.jpg


Starring Will Smith
:lolbron:
 

Easy-E

TSC's Ric Flair | Heel
Supporter
Joined
Jun 8, 2012
Messages
54,586
Reputation
9,875
Daps
162,412
Reppin
Negativity (Kayfabe)
Sitting around hoping a white company makes a white character black is lame as hell, IMO.
While he's based on Malcom, I can't see how it would not involve his Holocaust origins.

He's not. And the Holocaust is the main reason he hates humans.

It is intergril to his character arc. Instead of hoping he turns black. Demand the already black characters get screentime.

For the life of me, I don't see why ppl overlook the fact Monica Rambeau should've been the MCU Captain Marvel, not fukking Carol Danvers.

But, let's wish they make a black Thor. :francis:
 
Top