Even after watching three seasons, I still can't make up my mind whether I like it or not - let alone work out if it's good or not.
It handles some things masterfully well, but with its campy nature it can veer off course where other things don't quite hit like they're supposed to. As the seasons have gone on it's seemingly become too convoluted with the story it's trying to tell. The X-Files stencil is too heavy-handed at times, and distracts from what makes it unique, which exacerbates the fact that it doesn't quite lean right into its zaniness, and is more generically 'a world of weird'.