Dr. Tommy Curry - Failure of Black Studies and Intersectionality
- Thread starter AlainLocke
- Start date
Indiglow Meta (R$G)
Ultra.
Indiglow Meta (R$G)
Ultra.
The burden of proof is on you. Where is the data backing YOUR claims?
"did you even reaaaaad it"
This is a male dominant message board populated by (some) men who were socialized to engage in masculine behaviors...that usually means checking each other for INFORMATIONAL ACCURACY, since our interactions are based on exchanging information and experience...and not the emotional content of it.
This is why you're so resistant. It doesn't FEEL true to you. It isn't YOUR truth...it's THE TRUTH.
I don't know why you're expecting accountability from her.
Indiglow Meta (R$G)
Ultra.
Oh I don't, this is a performative act.
For the panders who aren't hustling and give quarter to birthing vessels who can't generate their own thoughts.
I'll post stats and reports everything else you ar saying is irrelevant.
I stated what the reports said so clearly I read it.
Fact checking is not inherent of masculine behavior but of someone with deductive reasoning.
This a message board...topics range.
As for the last sentence...this is your assumption. The only emotional person in our interaction is you not I. And you inserted yourself in a conversation where you were not included.
Indiglow Meta (R$G)
Ultra.
Nice try, we're still waiting for the data.
Not "Rainn" data.
Not "Black feminist studies" data.
The actual data from source. No article "slanting" the data. Just the data.
Where is your counter data? You can talk about what you're willing/about to do until evening...we want the proof.
Indiglow Meta (R$G)
Ultra.
Indiglow Meta (R$G)
Ultra.
Indiglow Meta (R$G)
Ultra.
I am running errands and I'll post data when I am good and ready. Ignore not ignore I don't care.
@Indiglow Meta (R$G)
@Indiglow Meta (R$G)
You guys are removing her right to make an arguement regardless of evidence. Mansplaining.
Derailment
https://bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/vi.pdf
Page 5: Female murder victims are substantially more likely than male murder victims to have been killed by an intimate. From 1976-96, 18.9% of women victims were murdered by husbands, 1.4% by ex-husbands, and 9.4.% by non marital partners. Over the same period, 3.7% of male victims were killed by wives,0.2% by ex-wives, and 2.0% by non marital partners
Page 6: Intimate murders accounted for 30% of all female murders and 6% of all male murders. the 32,580 spouses who were murder victims between 1976 and 1996, about 6 in 10 were women.
More important:
Let's evaluate this much toted quote supposedly proving black women violence:
Page 8: Between 1976 and 1989 more black men were killed by their wives than black women were killed by their husbands.
No one seems to quote the rest of that paragraph of:After 1990 the order was reversed, and the murder rate among black wives and ex-wives was higher than that among black husbands and ex-husbands.
Also page 8: The decline in the rate of intimate murder among black husbands/ex-husbands has been greater than for any other category of intimate murder victims.
Also, the study shows some drastic number changes
Page 7 : In 1976 the per capita rate of intimate murders among blacks was nearly 11 times that among whites; But in 1996 the black rate was just over 4 times higher than the white rate.
also
In 1976 the per capita rate of intimate murder of black men was nearly 19 times higher than that of white men. The rate among black females that year was 7 times higher than the rate among white females. In 1996 the black male rate was 8 times that of white males, and the black female rate was 3 times higher than the white female rate.
Page vii: The National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS), which gathers data on criminal victimization from a national sample was started in 1972. But in the late 80's (86 on) the Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS), sought to improve the NCVS components to enhance the measurement of crimes including rape,sexual assault, and intimate and family violence. A new questionnaire was created and it was phased in from January 1992 through June 1993. This new questionnaire provided a higher estimated counts of incidents of intimate violence than the old questionnaire
Data on their own without proper interpretation is useless.
Page 5: Female murder victims are substantially more likely than male murder victims to have been killed by an intimate. From 1976-96, 18.9% of women victims were murdered by husbands, 1.4% by ex-husbands, and 9.4.% by non marital partners. Over the same period, 3.7% of male victims were killed by wives,0.2% by ex-wives, and 2.0% by non marital partners
Page 6: Intimate murders accounted for 30% of all female murders and 6% of all male murders. the 32,580 spouses who were murder victims between 1976 and 1996, about 6 in 10 were women.
More important:
Let's evaluate this much toted quote supposedly proving black women violence:
Page 8: Between 1976 and 1989 more black men were killed by their wives than black women were killed by their husbands.
No one seems to quote the rest of that paragraph of:After 1990 the order was reversed, and the murder rate among black wives and ex-wives was higher than that among black husbands and ex-husbands.
Also page 8: The decline in the rate of intimate murder among black husbands/ex-husbands has been greater than for any other category of intimate murder victims.
Also, the study shows some drastic number changes
Page 7 : In 1976 the per capita rate of intimate murders among blacks was nearly 11 times that among whites; But in 1996 the black rate was just over 4 times higher than the white rate.
also
In 1976 the per capita rate of intimate murder of black men was nearly 19 times higher than that of white men. The rate among black females that year was 7 times higher than the rate among white females. In 1996 the black male rate was 8 times that of white males, and the black female rate was 3 times higher than the white female rate.
Page vii: The National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS), which gathers data on criminal victimization from a national sample was started in 1972. But in the late 80's (86 on) the Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS), sought to improve the NCVS components to enhance the measurement of crimes including rape,sexual assault, and intimate and family violence. A new questionnaire was created and it was phased in from January 1992 through June 1993. This new questionnaire provided a higher estimated counts of incidents of intimate violence than the old questionnaire
Data on their own without proper interpretation is useless.
