Donny Brasco is a better movie than Goodfellas

Better movie?

  • Goodfellas

    Votes: 47 92.2%
  • Donny Brasco

    Votes: 4 7.8%

  • Total voters
    51

MartyMcFly

What's up doc, can we rock?
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
59,888
Reputation
9,170
Daps
160,981
Reppin
P.G. County


The acting of Pacino in this scene...and during the whole movie....It was another level to me..Agree to disagree. The way he talks, walks, acts, everything.


That's one great performance (Pacino) and one good performance (Depp) vs a movie with incredible or all-time performances top to bottom. Including Lorraine Bracco. Goodfellas is a lot more than the sum of its parts. Donnie Brasco is a great gangster flick but Goodfellas is high art
 

MartyMcFly

What's up doc, can we rock?
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
59,888
Reputation
9,170
Daps
160,981
Reppin
P.G. County
Hell no! Casino is classic. Pesci was a savage. Sharon Stone killed it. DeNiro was A-1. I'll take Casino all day over Goodfellas.

It can be classic but also not be as good of a movie breh. And nah it's not. Goodfellas is all around great performances and isn't Scorsese copying himself which is exactly what he did in Casino
 

Flywin Lannister

Superstar
Joined
May 4, 2014
Messages
11,186
Reputation
1,627
Daps
39,552
Reppin
Lannister Bloodline
On paper this is a completely ridiculous statement.

But.. I may not have given Donnie Brasco the credit it deserves. My main issue with the movie is how Donnie got into the mob.

This is apparently how it happened, but it seems far-fetched.

You simply don’t just get and gain trust from mobsters.

Also this Pacino part where he is basically a mini-mob boss with not much clout who keeps on borrowing money

This undermines his power and how dangerous he is and.. yeah it’s a problem for the movie.

But: I’m going to give this one another shot. I like the movie quite a bit but Goodfellas for so many reasons (DeNiro and Pesci for starters, the many insane scenes, the amazing directing job and just the feel) really stands out.

I must say that for me too the weak link is Ray Liotta. He did the best he could but came across least ‘real’.

Nice thread op
 

Flywin Lannister

Superstar
Joined
May 4, 2014
Messages
11,186
Reputation
1,627
Daps
39,552
Reppin
Lannister Bloodline
Hell no! Casino is classic. Pesci was a savage. Sharon Stone killed it. DeNiro was A-1. I'll take Casino all day over Goodfellas.
Really?

I love and have both, but DeNiro’s character is quite soft (spoilers ahead) cause his chick’s got him (the boss) in his pocket.

He ends up doing an entertainment show...

Pesci and DeNiro are the movie and Stone does an amazing job being annoying

But better than Goodfellaz seems a stretch even if you base it on story vs story (obviously Casino is a great movie)
 

jay211

Superstar
Joined
May 25, 2012
Messages
15,344
Reputation
1,432
Daps
42,416
Reppin
NULL
Goodfellas > Casino > Carlito's Way > Donnie Brasco

:gucci::patrice: I love Carlito's way. But it's not better than Donnie Brasco.

The Godfather > Casino > Goodfellas > Scarface > Donnie Brasco > The Departed > Blow > Carlito's Way
 

zayk35

Superstar
Joined
Jul 21, 2012
Messages
11,877
Reputation
2,161
Daps
42,769
Reppin
Escondido California
Casino was my intro to gangster flicks so it won't be moved from my no.1 spot...with that said Goodfellas and Donnie Brascoe are right there with the edge going to Goodfellas..... but I could see why one would prefer one over the other
 
Top