mvp_status
Superstar
Yea if we're gonna knock Melo, make the argument that the teams he's had should've had higher seedings to begin with but made a habit of losing games to teams they should beat on paper in the regular season.
Do y'all think the media is too negative towards Carmelo?
- Thread starter Slaimon Khan Shah
- Start date
Yea if we're gonna knock Melo, make the argument that the teams he's had should've had higher seedings to begin with but made a habit of losing games to teams they should beat on paper in the regular season.
Melo Might Not Be Top Tier Like The Jordans, Kobes And LeBrons Of The League But He's Above The Likes Of A Tracy McGrady
At some point in your career you have to beat a team youre not supposed to beat.
True... Except he did that year he lost to the lakers (didn't he? Im not sure but they demolished the hornets I forget who they played the 2nd round)
Sly Cookin
based
My point is he didn't demand a trade so don't say he did . He could of played out his contract and screwed Denver .I go out allot and i see him out, i see Stat out more tbh, and are you saying he wanted to stay in Denver? Really?with his wife making moves in NYC? Okay....
You follow the teams system melo wasn't out there being a turnstile on defense either . His primary role was to score , why isn't gallo playing elite defense over there ? Or kd?
I know smh this guy . Let's say he has run into them how do you judge what's too much ? Melo has one subpar for him season in which it's a lockout and he'd injured now that means he's in the club too much ?unless francis is the club owner I bet he more likely than melo was affected by going to the club
McGrady was better playmaker and had a better all around game
He wasnt even elite for 10 seasons
he was finished by Melos age
Sly Cookin
based
He wasnt even elite for 10 seasons
look man melo my dude, but seeing as your a knicks fan, you will see in three years that his career ain't mean shyt
InstantKlassik
...
He wasnt even elite for 10 seasons
EXACTLY, people may or may not realize that McGrady's shelf life as a great player/his prime was only like 4 years (02'-06')
Sly Cookin
based
01-08 friend
InstantKlassik
...
I'll give you 01', but 08'...really?01-08 friend
but i'm talking about as one of the top 5 players in the league. 06' was his last year as an elite player imo. By that time Bron and Wade were already starting if not already eclipsing him.
Sly Cookin
based
08 he led the rockets to a 22 game win streak, only an elite player could lead a team of decent players through that buddy
AVXL
Laughing at you n*ggaz like “ha ha ha”
No. When you factor in all the fanboys with the legit criticism that he's got, it's fair to me 
He's singlehandedly the most OVERRATED "superstar" player in the league. Knicks fans will complain, but let's be reality. Dude is NOT winning a championship as the main superstar player on your team
He's singlehandedly the most OVERRATED "superstar" player in the league. Knicks fans will complain, but let's be reality. Dude is NOT winning a championship as the main superstar player on your team
As others have said he's actually had it pretty good considering his profile. It's changed recently but it's still not extreme as what I have seen others players recieve.
A 6'8, 250 lb a nikka with range and no history of off court trouble will have trouble finding a job? AI's problem was his size, his ego, and off court issues. Mostly his size though.
A 6'8, 250 lb a nikka with range and no history of off court trouble will have trouble finding a job? AI's problem was his size, his ego, and off court issues. Mostly his size though.
No. When you factor in all the fanboys with the legit criticism that he's got, it's fair to me
He's singlehandedly the most OVERRATED "superstar" player in the league. Knicks fans will complain, but let's be reality. Dude is NOT winning a championship as the main superstar player on your team
Same Can Be Said For Dominique Wilkens