"Detroit", 2017 Kathryn Bigelow film on the Detroit Riots

HHR

Do what you love
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
19,021
Reputation
1,622
Daps
39,392
It showed what happened. Would you rather they pretend the racist cops didn't walk free in the end? What would manufacturing a fictional "loss" for the cop and the white power structure have accomplished?

I wanted them to give more than a cursory nod to that white power structure.
 

CarbonBraddock

You will be trolled
Joined
May 13, 2015
Messages
17,170
Reputation
8,183
Daps
80,808
was going to go see this in about ten minutes but now having second thoughts. don't need to see black people getting brutalized anymore.
 

wickedsm

Auntie Mozelle
Supporter
Joined
Jul 26, 2015
Messages
14,567
Reputation
12,760
Daps
92,599
I wanted to kill somebody after the movie

I can't imagine the book

I had read the book years ago, so I already knew "how the story ended"
I didn't really want to go, the Mr did. And I really want to support movies with black leads and black stories...
So we went yesterday.

Watching it play out on screen was even worse
I left the theater sick to my stomach
Acid reflux still acting up 24 hrs later


:mjcry:
 

Guvnor

Da Speculative Spectacle®
Joined
Jan 17, 2017
Messages
23,271
Reputation
4,892
Daps
33,581
Reppin
BKLYN
Amazing movie though I hated the uncle tom cop and wanted him to get shot.

I also thought it was hard to see dude just give up on his dreams like that. Sucks this was based on a real story, damn life can be a cold son of a bytch.

What a story, im depressed :mjcry:
 

Roman Brady

Nobody Lives Forever
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,749
Reputation
-1,050
Daps
14,884
Just seen this, haven't stopped clenching my jaw or eye balling cacs since

It was shot well, intense in moments and really captured the 60s civil rights era. However my fears that this is a story being told through the lens of a white were proven right. It was painfully obvious they were given an edict to not paint the police Or national guard as pigs. Making out one of the murders was due to miscommunication not malice? The one cop that found the front man uttering lines like "how could any human being do this" "I got you brother" talk about laying it thick..

All in all while it was compelling I hate that this is the movie bigelow choose to toe the line on narrative wise, what a cop out.


Ps I don't really understand why boyega's character was on trial. He wasn't a cop and he didn't assault or shoot anyone he was just there
 
Last edited:

Dillah810

Flat Girther
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
44,746
Reputation
10,551
Daps
172,453
Reppin
Flint, Michigan
Ps I don't really understand why boyega's character was on trial. He wasn't a cop and he didn't assault or shoot anyone he was just there
From the movie's standpoint, one the people at the hotel ID'd him being at the scene when the crimes happened.

In real life, it's unclear how deep Melvin Dismukes's (the guy Boyega was playing) involvement was in that incident. Some of the victims said that Dismukes partook in some of the beatings himself. That's why he got a shytload of death threats from the Black Panthers.
 

Roman Brady

Nobody Lives Forever
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,749
Reputation
-1,050
Daps
14,884
From the movie's standpoint, one the people at the hotel ID'd him being at the scene when the crimes happened.

In real life, it's unclear how deep Melvin Dismukes's (the guy Boyega was playing) involvement was in that incident. Some of the victims said that Dismukes partook in some of the beatings himself. That's why he got a shytload of death threats from the Black Panthers.
I had a feeling he must have did more shyt than just being the mediator that the movie was trying to portray. They could have at least had a scene where he was coerced into beating someone as some form of initiation the way he just rolled with them and they didn't bat an eye lid till the very end where the 2 cops block his passage was odd
 

TheGodling

Los Ingobernables de Sala de Cine
Joined
May 21, 2013
Messages
20,078
Reputation
5,624
Daps
70,597
Reppin
Rotterdam
This movie had its problems but in the end it did what it needed to do for most of the audience, and that's show police brutality at work as well as the environment where many know it's happening but wash their hands of it. Some of the stuff really didn't work for me like the incredibly hamfisted and artificial dialogue, and in fact most of the movie's scenes felt so "constructed" to create a reaction that I had more trouble to buy it than I felt I should have.
 
Top