Lol, I’m not being close minded, you just missed my point, I just talked on if it was made with open world in mind, but I’m gonna repeat it anyway, if the game was made to be open world, then other elements need to be introduced, like side quests, things that take you of course of the main story so the big open world has a reason to be there, this does not work with The story and writing of TLOU, so if the game is made to be open world bits would have to be adjusted, not just gameplay but probably big parts of the narrative since main story beats are further apart, padding is added, the tension and urgency of the story is stripped away..even the camera isn’t going to be focused the same way nor are the interiors going to be as explorable or detailed, so regarding this discussion..it’s kinda pointless, because you take all that away and we’re not really talking about the same game anymore are we?
in fact, ironically...what you have left is something similar to Days Gone lol