Civil War | Discussion Thread | A24 (4/24/2024, Dir/Writer. Alex Garland, starring Kirsten Dunst)

Roid Jones

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
54,490
Reputation
7,077
Daps
162,084
Average, I was expecting this to provide a nuanced take on the situation it presented
 

ShaDynasty

Chaos - The Album
Joined
May 22, 2014
Messages
4,049
Reputation
988
Daps
7,864
I liked the film. I thought more than anything else it was influenced by Full Metal Jacket though, which is already a polarizing film.

People had expectations based on the marketing that was definitely misleading, but its not like theres no action. Its a cerebral flick based around journalism but with some solid action scenes.

And they just wanted to do the last film in the oval office for effect I think. It makes for a better scene than 'anonymous bunker: interior'.
 

KingDanz

Veteran
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
14,885
Reputation
4,609
Daps
73,149
Reppin
NULL
since when do press and photographers participate in full-on firefights and gun battles, armed with nothing but a camera, casually snapping each other getting shot? who were they even trying to get this footage for, in a failed country that was down to 8 or 9 people protecting the president?

the premise was almost too stupid for words :mjlol:
:dead: this
 

Macallik86

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Dec 4, 2016
Messages
6,583
Reputation
1,463
Daps
21,536
I avoided this movie because I thought it was gonna be some #bothsides bs but finally watched it today.

The marketing definitely drew in the wrong crowd in retrospect. I was pleasantly surprised altho I can see ppl being disappointed if they were getting a war movie. Personally I should've known not to doubt A24.

It's an ode to war journalism and the actual civil war is lowkey not really relevant at all. Definitely shades of NIghtcrawler with a large amount of overlap and a mirror being reflected back about professionals. There was one big similarity with Nightcrawler's ending except it was reversed in Civil War and the protege gets the mentor killed instead vice versa in Nightcrawler.
 

daemonova

hit it, & I didn't go Erykah Badu crazy, #yallmad
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
43,998
Reputation
3,510
Daps
72,524
GdbHPKZXwAE_Ekx
 

Jmare007

pico pal q lee
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
44,580
Reputation
5,925
Daps
109,129
Reppin
Chile
Finally saw this. I appreciate these type of movies getting made in today's Hollywood landscape. It was a good watch and as an outsider (from South America) it was cool to see a typical civil war scenario being presented in current day U.S.A.

But I wouldn't call this a great film either. There's some themes that are really well done, but there's a lot of stuff that felt half baked. And I'm not talking about the politics side of the film either, I honestly didn't mind the fact we weren't really explained much about that.

Moura's and Dunst characters were all over the place. Specially Moura, who understandably lost his shyt after Meth Damon killed two colleagues, almost murdered him as well AND then lost both Sammy and -he thought at the time- the exclusive story they made the trip for in the first place. And then Lee gets shot and he's like "who cares, the President is over there". I feel like the movie told me Moura wouldn't have reacted that way after everything he went through in this journey. And the point of that scene being how war fukks people up didn't add up to what seemed to be his arc. On the other hand, I did believe Jessie's character would've done and reacted the way she did, even if the transformation was very quick.

Lee finally breaking down mentally, but getting her shyt together to miraculously figure out the President was in the White House and then get shot was also very weird. Like, it was as simple as her continuing to be mentally broken -her scene in the shower and some of dialogue tells us she's more than fed up with this bullshyt-, the military saying the President was still inside and Jessie dragging Lee to the WH. What happened after could've went a number of different ways (Lee snaps out of it to save Jessie or Jessie gets shot/killed for being reckless as Lee anticipated earlier in the film, just to name a couple of scenarios).
 
Last edited:

2 Up 2 Down

Veteran
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
27,647
Reputation
2,645
Daps
66,309
Reppin
NULL
I thought it was fine but just given the nature of the subject matter it felt strange at how apolitical it was
 

klientel

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
18,099
Reputation
1,840
Daps
76,627
Great premise and had to the potential to be an amazing movie. But it was alright in the end. I think with the current political climate my expectations were just way too high.
 

daemonova

hit it, & I didn't go Erykah Badu crazy, #yallmad
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
43,998
Reputation
3,510
Daps
72,524
1. Challengers
2. Dune 2
3. Humanist Vampire Seeking Consenting Suicidal Person
4. Strange Darling
5. Red Rooms
6. Civil War
7. Longlegs
8. Furiosa
9. Touch
10. Evil does not exist
Hmmmm :jbhmm:
 

Cole Cash

They took a hammer and sickle to my back
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
8,750
Reputation
7,386
Daps
30,739
Reppin
Baltimore Maryland
The only good parts were when they finally shot that crying Asian nikka and Jesse Plemons yelled “CHINA” I was dying .

Sniper calling them retarded.

Ending shootout. Entire movie was cowardly, no mention of race , just straight up cowardly.
 
Top