Chris Webber Or Amare Stoudemire

[WuDatWuDat]

I might be totally off but i feel like C-Webb's prime and/or peak years last longer than Amare's. So i'll go with Webber.

They did. I think Amare at his peak was a little better but Webb lasted longer at a high level.

 

[PSIEGE27]

Webber easily without a second thought

 

[mvp_status]

Webber easily

Amare couldn't pass out of a double team to save his life

 

[scarhead]

CWEBB

 

[Manuel Hot Pepper Lopez]

CWebb will get HOF consideration
Amare....

 

[Danie84]

CWebb easily, Stat was always fool's gold especially in his last Suns run

 

[Osmosis]

Amare's prime was a lot better

 

[Reggie]

Amare was that dude but I don't understand this at his best he was better then C-Webb. Amare showed at his peak he was a 25-26 ppg scorer with about 9 rebounds to match. C-Webb was at 27 and 13 along with dropping 4 to 5 assists a night too and being more versatile. I'm going with Webber all day.

 

[LuckyLibra619]

Those old King teams were so fun to watch. C-Webb, Mike Bibby, Doug Christie, Vlade, Peja.

 

[Long Live The Mamba]

Im takin C Webb over struggle knees Amare..

 

[Penny 95]

Prime C Webb was like a smaller Shaq that could shoot the mid range jump shot. He was an underrated defender as well. Dude was a beast. Plus, Webber won everywhere he went. He even made the Bullets a playoff contender, him and rasheed wallace. Amare was great too, but he couldn't take over games at will like Webber did. And he's offensive output was predicated on the type of system he played in. His style of play was perfect for the run and gun offense. I'm going with Webber.

 

[ManBearPig]

They did. I think Amare at his peak was a little better but Webb lasted longer at a high level.

Amare wasnt better and only morons think otherwise

 

[Jplaya2023]

pre knee injury c webb >>>> prime amare

webber was right up there with Duncan and KG before he fukked his knee up and better than dirk

 

[Lootpack]

Webber no doubt

 

[Manuel Hot Pepper Lopez]

Prime C Webb was like a smaller Shaq that could shoot the mid range jump shot. He was an underrated defender as well. Dude was a beast. Plus, Webber won everywhere he went. He even made the Bullets a playoff contender, him and rasheed wallace. Amare was great too, but he couldn't take over games at will like Webber did. And he's offensive output was predicated on the type of system he played in. His style of play was perfect for the run and gun offense. I'm going with Webber.

It was actually after the Bullets traded Sheed after his rookie year for Rod Strickland that they started making noise