Chris Webber Or Amare Stoudemire

[Juggalo Fred]

Amare

 

[Wacky D]

tough one.

both were hindered by injuries.

i want to say prime amare was better but iirc, webber got hit with the injuries earlier than amare.

and webb changed his style up and was able to remain elite for a good while after the injuries.

so i gotta go with webber even tho amare had the better peak.

I may go with Amare. Before Carmelo came to New York Amare was playing like a franchise all-star. I'm not sure Amare was as much reliant on Steve Nash as assumed.

yea he wasnt reliant on nash at all.

amare was big before nash even got to phoenix.
and he was a front-runner for mvp in new york.

injuries ended that new york run tho. carmelo had nothing to do with that.