1/11
@tsarnick
Ethan Mollick says students don't raise their hands in class as much because they don't want to expose their ignorance when AI can answer their questions, and the use of AI is leading to the illusion of competence and lower test scores
https://video.twimg.com/ext_tw_video/1847075142259843072/pu/vid/avc1/720x720/_oFx1B48TzMws-1F.mp4
2/11
@tsarnick
Source (thanks to @curiousgangsta):
https://invidious.poast.org/watch?v=xvxPFH16Bvg
3/11
@emollick
he research I was referring to.
[Quoted tweet]
AI can help learning... when it isn't a crutch.
There are now multiple controlled experiments showing that students who use AI to get answers to problems hurts learning (even though they think they are learning), but that students who use AI as a tutor perform better on tests.
4/11
@tsarnick
interesting, thanks for the extra context!
5/11
@joehenriod
I had a teacher when I was in high school that bribed me to always raise my hand and ask really stupid questions before everyone else.
It set the bar for participation as really low, because everyone knew they could AT LEAST contribute something better than I did.
6/11
@tsarnick
7/11
@BobbyGRG
Not sure that asking AI for questions wouldn't provide learning. Students might need though to learn how to ask AI to learn the most. A (good) human teacher will try to double check and make sure that students understood. An AI will just provide an explanation and unless re-prompted to extend or explain otherwise that would be it. Easily improvable with an application wrapper instructed to do similar. Did that wrapper cot app for my kids like in april 2023... now they use chatpgt directly using the right patterns, verification, etc. to activate their learning. That what students need to learn...
8/11
@CallumMacClark
Teachers and lecturers can try all they want to ban this technology but it's not going anywhere. I applaud the students who are using this. also interesting to think that these students are learning how to interact with LLM's not through courses but through usage.
9/11
@ravisyal
Easy access to great teachers will lead to increased learning.
10/11
@Chris_Brannigan
An ai tutor would ask the student follow up questions, give the option of worked examples and other methods to embed / check learning
11/11
@AntDX316
I find with AI that when you keep seeing what is needed in a program, you get used to sticking to what works, which is a good thing as it's constant training with the very best.
To post tweets in this format, more info here: https://www.thecoli.com/threads/tips-and-tricks-for-posting-the-coli-megathread.984734/post-52211196