Carmelo anthony never made first team all nba in his career

[Mr. Jack Napier]

Hard to be overrated being 11th all-time in scoring. Not to mention that Duncan, KG, LeBron & KD were all ahead of him.

Dude is a bona-fide hall of famer, whether folks like it or not.

 

[KidJSoul]

He was a great scorer but a little below KD level

And his defense, passing, and intangibles were straight up basura

 

[mvp_status]

Hard to be overrated being 11th all-time in scoring. Not to mention that Duncan, KG, LeBron & KD were all ahead of him.

Dude is a bona-fide hall of famer, whether folks like it or not.

9th

 

[Damnshow]

You sound like making all nba 1st team is so easy to do.

Also how the hell is that a factor if someone should get signed or not?

Off top of my head Pierce, Allen, Manu, Parker, Gasol never had this award and they had long careers and won championships. Were they overrated too?

 

[Mr. Jack Napier]

9th

 

[mvp_status]

Lol Melo is 9th on the scoring list not 11th

 

[Mr. Jack Napier]

Lol Melo is 9th on the scoring list not 11th

9th on the NBA list, 11th on the NBA/ABA list

 

[Shadow King]

He had better guys before him. LeBron, Durant, Dirk, KG and Duncan is hard to beat

The last 3 players were well into their 30s while Carmelo was in his prime. He should have been able to get one.

 

[Shadow King]

You sound like making all nba 1st team is so easy to do.

Also how the hell is that a factor if someone should get signed or not?

Off top of my head Pierce, Allen, Manu, Parker, Gasol never had this award and they had long careers and won championships. Were they overrated too?

I don't necessarily agree with "Melo is overrated" but of the compared names, the last 3 of the 5 would get a good deal of pushback if they were named Top 10 at their position (depending what position Gasol is listed).

Those aren't comparable names.

 

[Wolfpac]

Melo isn't overrated he just chose money over a legacy. He had an opportunity to go to a team that could be a contender but chose the knicks instead

Shoulda gone to the Bulls in 2014.

 

[Software]

Shoulda gone to the Bulls in 2014.

Yep they were already one of the best defenses in the league so it would have been a great fit with him as the primary scoring option while his teammates covering for his weaknesses on defense

 

[gdatruth]

He came in the same year Bron and during his career other premiere forwards including Bron, KD & Kawi to name a few
it aint that suprising he never made 1st team

 

[Roger king]

He is a great scorer but he never even got to the finals or made first team all NBA, was there any year of carmelo career you could argue he was top 5 in the league? The best argument is his scoring title year and even that is very debatable as well

 

[Collateral]

Melo was never overrated, his career was just a disappointment considering how amazing he was at Cuse

 

[ALonelyDad]

The last 3 players were well into their 30s while Carmelo was in his prime. He should have been able to get one.

Idk about their age, but it wasn't as late. They were all very elite

2009 Dirk was the latest Dirk got over him, 2007 for Duncan, 2008 when that big 3 team happened for KG. That is just tough to beat, those guys are all top 20 players of all time

Year-by-year All-NBA Teams | NBA.com

Take a look back at every All-NBA team in league history.

www.nba.com