Carlito's Way is better than Scarface. Agree or disagree?

Carlito's Way is better than Scarface


  • Total voters
    70
  • Poll closed .

ThaRealness

Superstar
Joined
Mar 18, 2013
Messages
19,853
Reputation
2,355
Daps
36,825
Reppin
Madison
I don't know about Carlito's Way but to me Casino, Goodfellas, Donnie Brasco and A Bronx Tale are all better than Scarface. And I think Scarface is a great movie too.
Couldn't make it past 30 minutes wit the way Johnny Depp portrayed Brasco
the real Donnie Brasco was a cool motherfukker :yeshrug:
 

Killigraphy

Banned
Joined
Mar 8, 2015
Messages
8,325
Reputation
-2,259
Daps
17,515
Reppin
NYC black coffee tough guys aka the Stoozy Boys
While Scarface had more character development, Carlito's Way has more heart. He was a gangster trying to get out, in Scarface he's a small time hustler trying to stay in for good. Carlito is more endearing, he has a girl who loves him, people who respect him, but his mercy made him soft , at least soft enough to not kill Benny. In Scarface he just goes out of control and becomes/stays a major douche. Charlie is more likeable, the movie, that much more dreary and filled with more suspense. You feel bad for Carlito, you don't ever feel bad for Tony, you just know he's gonna go out guns blazing.
 
Last edited:

Rell Lauren

Banned
Joined
Nov 30, 2016
Messages
29,001
Reputation
-2,888
Daps
111,796
Reppin
NYC
fukk that, Carlitos Way 2: Rise to Power (With Diddy :lolbron:) or Scarface: The World Is Yours video game, where Tony came back to life?

He didn't come back to life. He killed the assassin with the shotgun before he got him.

As far as the flicks go, Carlitos Way is a superior film to Scarface. I can watch it every time it comes on. I just can't do that with Scarface. I think it's ok at best.
 

Zero

Wig-Twisting Season
Joined
Nov 15, 2013
Messages
76,784
Reputation
27,180
Daps
364,170
:gucci: nikka what

Gotta be. Only impressionable, irresponsible teenagers think what Tony did in that movie was dope. This dude came from nothing, got in the drug game, went against everything he was taught, went against the people who taught him left from right, killed his right hand man because of a sister complex, and why? Because fukk YOU MANG
SS5ShwYL_o.gif


You see where all that got him but people love idolizing him...who the fukk would want to be this raving lunatic?

Besides, take away Pacino's performance and Moroder's score and you're not working with a whole lot.


Wasnt there like 10 threads on this already?
:what:

Anyway...

Carlito>>>>> just off the court room scene alone.

My younger brother actually did like a rendition of that shyt one time he was in court.
:deadmanny:

"Not YOUR honor!!"
:russ:
"And it didnt take no 30 years like your honor thought, but only five!!! :umad:"

:laff:
 

swampfox

Pro
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
338
Reputation
20
Daps
1,042
Reppin
NULL
Both classics. Carlito just had more depth. Also dropped more jewels in my opinion, which gives it more entertaining value.
 

mastermind

Rest In Power Kobe
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
62,611
Reputation
5,967
Daps
165,273
Scarface is one of the most overrated movies I’ve ever seen. Hasn’t aged well and has the depth of a gnat.


Carlito’s Way is way better and it’s not like that movie was an amazing spectacle either.
 

Dreamzeedream

Banned
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
12,098
Reputation
-1,166
Daps
15,297
Reppin
NULL
Gotta be. Only impressionable, irresponsible teenagers think what Tony did in that movie was dope. This dude came from nothing, got in the drug game, went against everything he was taught, went against the people who taught him left from right, killed his right hand man because of a sister complex, and why? Because fukk YOU MANG
SS5ShwYL_o.gif


You see where all that got him but people love idolizing him...who the fukk would want to be this raving lunatic?

Besides, take away Pacino's performance and Moroder's score and you're not working with a whole lot.



"And it didnt take no 30 years like your honor thought, but only five!!! :umad:"

:laff:
Ohhh I thought you was talking about the movie as a whole. Your right tho. Alot if that had to do with that Cocaine... you see he said he fukked up once he got to the mansion and was sniff coke again
 

re'up

Veteran
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
20,269
Reputation
6,121
Daps
63,658
Reppin
San Diego
I remember around the time we all first watched Carlitos Way on DVD or VHS, early 2000's, my friend went to take a shower, and came out, dressed, and was doing the Carlito courtroom impression:

I am reinvigorated, re assimilated, RE HABILITATED

That shyt still kills me.
 
Top