Can a case be made that DMX is better than Nas?

Is DMX a better rapper than Nas

  • Yes

    Votes: 54 16.4%
  • No

    Votes: 275 83.6%

  • Total voters
    329

bigbadbossup2012

Biggest baddest boss
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
21,594
Reputation
-5,981
Daps
23,039
Since when was IDAHIH a masterfully produced album? lmao
Some albums are more artist driven. Some rely on both.
But dame did not lace dmx with crazy memorable beats on there.
shyt is hilarious
 

spliz

SplizThaDon
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
61,649
Reputation
9,422
Daps
205,411
Reppin
NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
Even if I was to accept your inaccurate 13 out 19 tracks story, 13/19 is not equal to 85%. :comeon:

You need to look at those production credits, breh. Of the 13 tracks, 7 are the only ones Dame produced by himself. 1 of them is a skit. How in the hell are you giving Dame Grease so much credit for that album anyway:what:
nikka he had his hands on 13 tracks on the album. That's around 75% of the production on X's BEST album that Dame Grease had a hand in. What fukkin real DMX fan feels the opposite of this shyt? I'm actually baffled. Dame Grease and PK was X's signature sound.
 
Last edited:

JYoung24

Young J
Joined
May 30, 2012
Messages
7,756
Reputation
-825
Daps
6,227
Reppin
NULL
I'll say this DMX is a great rapper. Had he not had problems with drugs he's be a top 15 of all time rapper, maybe even top 10 (that's a hard sell). To be honest as beloved as his 1st 3 albums are, none of them are classics (outside of being personal classics). Nas has earned the reputation of being a top rapper of all time. Even though I think he has only 2 classic albums, if you go song by song, Nas has it by a longshot.

dmx is a top 10 rapper tho. and nas has more than 2 classics
 

JYoung24

Young J
Joined
May 30, 2012
Messages
7,756
Reputation
-825
Daps
6,227
Reppin
NULL
DMX is possibly the most overrated rapper of all time. IDGAF what anyone says.

:pacspit:


It's not a myth. It was a general belief at the time. And the difference between Nas and DMX/Jay is that they were consistently themselves. Volume 3 Jay is still the same guy, even if Volume 3 wasn't as good as Volume 2, 1, or RD.

Nas went from street poet to mafia don. You could tell he was influenced by Biggie and others and started telling first person shooter type of stories. So he lost some of his direction and started following what other people were doing. You Owe Me Nas isn't the same guy as One Love Nas. And a lot of his fans wanted him to stay that guy.


Nah. Stop it. That was a general belief before Takeover. Nas wasn't in the mainstream consciousness by 2001, outside of Oochie Wally, which was a minor song dropped early in the year. It took the Jay beef and Stillmatic to bring him back by the end of the year. He had been cold for a while by then.

And you can tell, because he was everywhere between when Stillmatic and God's Son dropped. He made a comeback.

nastradaumus went plat bruh
 

bigbadbossup2012

Biggest baddest boss
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
21,594
Reputation
-5,981
Daps
23,039
nikka he had his hands on 13 tracks on the album. That's around 75% of the production on X's BEST album that Dame Grease had a hand in. What fukkin real DMX fan feels the opposite of this shyt? I'm actually baffled.
You think your opinion = facts.
You thinking IDAHIH is his goat album is opinion.
You thinking dame's beats made the album dope is opinion
You crediting him for addt. production as if he actually produced certain tracks is nonsense.
Because none of HIS beats or as good.
Grease having no big hits is fact.
 

Ineedmoney504

SOHH ICEY...WE EATIN
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
44,845
Reputation
3,489
Daps
99,846
Reppin
SOHH ICEY N.O.
You think your opinion = facts.
You thinking IDAHIH is his goat album is opinion.
You thinking dame's beats made the album dope is opinion
You crediting him for addt. production as if he actually produced certain tracks is nonsense.
Because none of HIS beats or as good.
Grease having no big hits is fact.
Idahh is easily his best album. And that ere/dark production was his signature and made the world fall in love
 

spliz

SplizThaDon
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
61,649
Reputation
9,422
Daps
205,411
Reppin
NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
Since when was IDAHIH a masterfully produced album? lmao
Some albums are more artist driven. Some rely on both.
But dame did not lace dmx with crazy memorable beats on there.
shyt is hilarious
The beats was signature X. They didn't have to be some crazy shyt. It was original and it fit him perfectly. Good beats are more than just bangers. People forget the creative and storytelling aspect of DMX. Which those beats fit perfectly. I'm not saying Swizz isn't an important part of DMX. I said he shouldn't have gotten RID of Dame Grease and PK. And Swizz gets all the credit when they were the ones instrumental in giving X his classic album.
 

spliz

SplizThaDon
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
61,649
Reputation
9,422
Daps
205,411
Reppin
NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
Idahh is easily his best album. And that ere/dark production was his signature and made the world fall in love
These nikkas couldn't have been X fans from the jump. This is shyt that shouldn't have to be explained. nikka over there talkin bout hits n shyt. When at the time. Most shyt bumpin out nikkas whips was The Intro. Damien. Stop Being Greedy. How's It Goin Down(Radio version was NOT better by the way). Etc. Ruff Ryder's Anthem was bumped heavy too but not initially over those tracks.
 
Last edited:

bigbadbossup2012

Biggest baddest boss
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
21,594
Reputation
-5,981
Daps
23,039
These nikkas couldn't have been X fans from the jump. This is shyt that shouldn't have to be explained. nikka over there talkin bout hits n shyt. When at the time. Most shyt bumpin out nikkas whips was The Intro. Damien. Stop Being Greedy. How's It Goin Down(Radio version was NOT better by the way). Etc. Ruff Ryder's Anthem was bumped heavy too but not initially over those tracks.
I had x's albums in 98' never thought dame's beats were dope.
so........?

lmao
 

spliz

SplizThaDon
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
61,649
Reputation
9,422
Daps
205,411
Reppin
NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
opinion.
what makes it the best besides you proclaiming it?
If dame made people fall in love why does swizz have all the bigger hits?
nikka that album didn't have huge hits but still saved Def Jam commercially and went like double out the gate. U trippin. Talkin bout hits n shyt and we talkin bout music. Matter fact. Ask DMX what his fav album is.
 

bigbadbossup2012

Biggest baddest boss
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
21,594
Reputation
-5,981
Daps
23,039
nikka that album didn't have huge hits but still saved Def Jam commercially and went like double out the gate. U trippin. Talkin bout hits n shyt and we talkin bout music. Matter fact. Ask DMX what his fav album is.
RR anthem is an iconic record and was loved by all.
Warren g saved def jam. Stop believing fairy tales.

Hits are music,music that resonated well.
 
Top